arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2005.06499quant-ph
收藏

超强耦合量子电动力学中材料截断导致的规范非不变性

Gauge non-invariance due to material truncation in ultrastrong-coupling QED

Adam Stokes, Ahsan Nazir

AI总结:

本文指出《自然·物理》2019年某研究提出的解决材料截断规范非不变性的方法基于错误数学断言,其生成的两能级模型在不同规范下不等价,库仑规范模型不准确,还强调超强耦合体系中向量空间相对性不可忽略。

摘要:

材料截断导致的规范非不变性最近已在强耦合量子电动力学的多个情境中得到探索。我们证明,《自然·物理》15卷803页(2019年)中最近提出的方法基于错误的数学断言,因此无法解决规范非不变性问题。该方法生成的新两能级模型在不同规范下并不等价。新的库仑规范模型对于《自然·物理》15卷803页(2019年)所考虑的体系不准确,而多极规范量子拉比模型在这些体系下是准确的。《自然·物理》15卷803页(2019年)中分析的模型并非来自正文提供的论证,而是来自多极规范内的截断,随后应用了截断的相位不变性原理。更一般地说,该原理可在任何规范内截断后应用,从而在所选规范内产生截断模型的等价类。属于不同规范的等价类并不等价,且截断的相位不变性原理未提供偏好特定类别的论据。通常,最优类取决于物理情境,包括可观测量、参数体系和所考虑的场模数量。我们还强调,规范模糊性与近似导致的规范非不变性并非同义。独立于材料截断,子系统预测可能因子系统的理论定义(由规范选择控制)而有很大差异,这构成了向量空间相对性的一个例子,且绝不与规范不变性矛盾。然而,在超强耦合体系中,这种相对性不再可被忽略。

英文摘要:

Gauge non-invariance due to material truncation has recently been explored in a number of contexts in strong-coupling QED. We show that the approach proposed recently in Nature Physics 15, 803 (2019) rests on an incorrect mathematical assertion and so does not resolve gauge non-invariance. It produces new two-level models that are not equivalent in different gauges. The new Coulomb-gauge model is inaccurate for the regimes considered in Nature Physics 15, 803 (2019), for which the multipolar-gauge quantum Rabi model is accurate. The models analysed in Nature Physics 15, 803 (2019) do not result from the argument provided in the main text, but instead from truncation within the multipolar-gauge followed by the application of a truncated phase-invariance principle. More generally, this principle can be applied following truncation in any gauge and it yields an equivalence class of truncated models within the gauge chosen. Equivalence classes belonging to different gauges are not equivalent and the truncated phase-invariance principle does not provide an argument to prefer a particular class. In general, the optimal class depends on the physical situation, including the observables, the parameter regime, and the number of field modes being considered. We also emphasise that gauge-ambiguities are not synonymous with gauge non-invariance due to approximations. Independent of material truncation subsystem predictions can be vastly different depending on the theoretical definitions of the subsystems, which are controlled by the gauge choice. This constitutes an example of vector-space relativity that in no way contradicts gauge-invariance. However, within ultrastrong-coupling regimes this relativity can no longer be ignored.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑