arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2005.00039stat.AP
收藏

基于置信加权多数投票的群体决策

Group Decisions based on Confidence Weighted Majority Voting

Sascha Meyen, Dorothee M. B. Sigg, Ulrike von Luxburg, Volker H. Franz

摘要:

背景:有报道称,在不确定性条件下做出决策时,群体的表现优于个体。在实验室环境中,真实的群体通常被模拟的群体所取代:而不是进行实际的群体讨论,个人的反应是通过数值计算来汇总的。虽然研究通常使用未加权多数投票(MV)进行这种汇总,但理论上最佳方法是置信加权多数投票(CWMV)-如果单个响应的置信度评级可用。然而,目前还不完全清楚如何以及理论推导的CWMV方法预测真正的群体决策和信心。因此,我们比较了使用CWMV和MV的模拟群体反应与真实群体反应。结果如下:基于CWMV的模拟群体决策的准确性与真实群体决策的准确性非常匹配,而基于MV的模拟群体决策的准确性较低。此外,CWMV很好地预测了群体对群体决策的信心。然而,个人和真实群体表现出对不自信的偏见,而CWMV则没有。结论:我们的研究结果强调了在调查群体决策时考虑个人信心的重要性:我们发现,真实群体可以聚合个人信心,使其与CWMV给出的最佳聚合相匹配。这意味着使用模拟群体决策的研究应该使用CWMV而不是MV。

英文摘要:

Background: It has repeatedly been reported that when making decisions under uncertainty, groups outperform individuals. In a lab setting, real groups are often replaced by simulated groups: Instead of performing an actual group discussion, individual responses are aggregated by a numerical computation. While studies typically use unweighted majority voting (MV) for this aggregation, the theoretically optimal method is confidence weighted majority voting (CWMV) -- if confidence ratings for the individual responses are available. However, it is not entirely clear how well the theoretically derived CWMV method predicts real group decisions and confidences. Therefore, we compared simulated group responses using CWMV and MV to real group responses. Results: Simulated group decisions based on CWMV matched the accuracy of real group decisions very well, while simulated group decisions based on MV showed lower accuracy. Also, CWMV well predicted the confidence that groups put into their group decisions. Yet, individuals and real groups showed a bias towards under-confidence while CWMV does not. Conclusion: Our results highlight the importance of taking into account individual confidences when investigating group decisions: We found that real groups can aggregate individual confidences such that they match the optimal aggregation given by CWMV. This implies that research using simulated group decisions should use CWMV and not MV.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑