Non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion remains an interesting but challenging speech processing task. Many style-transfer-inspired methods such as generative adversarial networks (GANs) and variational autoencoders (VAEs) have been proposed. Recently, AutoVC, a conditional autoencoders (CAEs) based method achieved state-of-the-art results by disentangling the speaker identity and speech content using information-constraining bottlenecks, and it achieves zero-shot conversion by swapping in a different speaker's identity embedding to synthesize a new voice. However, we found that while speaker identity is disentangled from speech content, a significant amount of prosodic information, such as source F0, leaks through the bottleneck, causing target F0 to fluctuate unnaturally. Furthermore, AutoVC has no control of the converted F0 and thus unsuitable for many applications. In the paper, we modified and improved autoencoder-based voice conversion to disentangle content, F0, and speaker identity at the same time. Therefore, we can control the F0 contour, generate speech with F0 consistent with the target speaker, and significantly improve quality and similarity. We support our improvement through quantitative and qualitative analysis.
Snap Research, Snap Inc.（Snap公司Snap研究院）；University of California, Los Angeles（加利福尼亚大学洛杉矶分校）
Singing voice conversion is a task to convert a song sang by a source singer to the voice of a target singer. In this paper, we propose using a parallel data free, many-to-one voice conversion technique on singing voices. A phonetic posterior feature is first generated by decoding singing voices through a robust Automatic Speech Recognition Engine (ASR). Then, a trained Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) with a Deep Bidirectional Long Short Term Memory (DBLSTM) structure is used to model the mapping from person-independent content to the acoustic features of the target person. F0 and aperiodic are…
We present a voice conversion solution using recurrent sequence to sequence modeling for DNNs. Our solution takes advantage of recent advances in attention based modeling in the fields of Neural Machine Translation (NMT), Text-to-Speech (TTS) and Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR). The problem consists of converting between voices in a parallel setting when {\it $<$source,target$>$} audio pairs are available. Our seq2seq architecture makes use of a hierarchical encoder to summarize input audio frames. On the decoder side, we use an attention based architecture used in recent TTS works. Since t…
Substantial improvements have been achieved in recent years in voice conversion, which converts the speaker characteristics of an utterance into those of another speaker without changing the linguistic content of the utterance. Nonetheless, the improved conversion technologies also led to concerns about privacy and authentication. It thus becomes highly desired to be able to prevent one's voice from being improperly utilized with such voice conversion technologies. This is why we report in this paper the first known attempt to perform adversarial attack on voice conversion. We introduce human …
Duke University（杜克大学）；Duke Kunshan University（昆山杜克大学）
In this paper, we propose an invertible deep learning framework called INVVC for voice conversion. It is designed against the possible threats that inherently come along with voice conversion systems. Specifically, we develop an invertible framework that makes the source identity traceable. The framework is built on a series of invertible $1\times1$ convolutions and flows consisting of affine coupling layers. We apply the proposed framework to one-to-one voice conversion and many-to-one conversion using parallel training data. Experimental results show that this approach yields impressive perf…
Voice conversion (VC) refers to transforming the speaker characteristics of an utterance without altering its linguistic contents. Many works on voice conversion require to have parallel training data that is highly expensive to acquire. Recently, the cycle-consistent adversarial network (CycleGAN), which does not require parallel training data, has been applied to voice conversion, showing the state-of-the-art performance. The CycleGAN based voice conversion, however, can be used only for a pair of speakers, i.e., one-to-one voice conversion between two speakers. In this paper, we extend the …
Vinai Research（维奈研究院）；Deezer Research and Development（迪泽研发中心）
Voice conversion is a challenging task which transforms the voice characteristics of a source speaker to a target speaker without changing linguistic content. Recently, there have been many works on many-to-many Voice Conversion (VC) based on Variational Autoencoder (VAEs) achieving good results, however, these methods lack the ability to disentangle speaker identity and linguistic content to achieve good performance on unseen speaker scenarios. In this paper, we propose a new method based on feature disentanglement to tackle many to many voice conversion. The method has the capability to dise…
We present an unsupervised non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion (VC) method using a generative adversarial network (GAN) called StarGAN v2. Using a combination of adversarial source classifier loss and perceptual loss, our model significantly outperforms previous VC models. Although our model is trained only with 20 English speakers, it generalizes to a variety of voice conversion tasks, such as any-to-many, cross-lingual, and singing conversion. Using a style encoder, our framework can also convert plain reading speech into stylistic speech, such as emotional and falsetto speech. Subjec…
Voice conversion (VC) consists of digitally altering the voice of an individual to manipulate part of its content, primarily its identity, while maintaining the rest unchanged. Research in neural VC has accomplished considerable breakthroughs with the capacity to falsify a voice identity using a small amount of data with a highly realistic rendering. This paper goes beyond voice identity and presents a neural architecture that allows the manipulation of voice attributes (e.g., gender and age). Leveraging the latest advances on adversarial learning of structured speech representation, a novel s…
Facebook AI Research（脸书人工智能研究院）；Tel Aviv University（特拉维夫大学）
We present a deep learning method for singing voice conversion. The proposed network is not conditioned on the text or on the notes, and it directly converts the audio of one singer to the voice of another. Training is performed without any form of supervision: no lyrics or any kind of phonetic features, no notes, and no matching samples between singers. The proposed network employs a single CNN encoder for all singers, a single WaveNet decoder, and a classifier that enforces the latent representation to be singer-agnostic. Each singer is represented by one embedding vector, which the decoder …
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign（伊利诺伊大学厄巴纳-香槟分校）；MIT-IBM Watson AI Lab（MIT-IBM沃森人工智能实验室）；IBM Research（IBM研究院）
Non-parallel many-to-many voice conversion, as well as zero-shot voice conversion, remain under-explored areas. Deep style transfer algorithms, such as generative adversarial networks (GAN) and conditional variational autoencoder (CVAE), are being applied as new solutions in this field. However, GAN training is sophisticated and difficult, and there is no strong evidence that its generated speech is of good perceptual quality. On the other hand, CVAE training is simple but does not come with the distribution-matching property of a GAN. In this paper, we propose a new style transfer scheme that…
The goal of voice conversion (VC) is to convert input voice to match the target speaker's voice while keeping text and prosody intact. VC is usually used in entertainment and speaking-aid systems, as well as applied for speech data generation and augmentation. The development of any-to-any VC systems, which are capable of generating voices unseen during model training, is of particular interest to both researchers and the industry. Despite recent progress, any-to-any conversion quality is still inferior to natural speech. In this work, we propose a new any-to-any voice conversion pipeline. Our…
University of California at Berkeley（加州大学伯克利分校）；Intel AI Lab（英特尔人工智能实验室）
We present a method for converting the voices between a set of speakers. Our method is based on training multiple autoencoder paths, where there is a single speaker-independent encoder and multiple speaker-dependent decoders. The autoencoders are trained with an addition of an adversarial loss which is provided by an auxiliary classifier in order to guide the output of the encoder to be speaker independent. The training of the model is unsupervised in the sense that it does not require collecting the same utterances from the speakers nor does it require time aligning over phonemes. Due to the …
This paper tackles GAN optimization and stability issues in the context of voice conversion. First, to simplify the conversion task, we propose to use spectral envelopes as inputs. Second we propose two adversarial weight training paradigms, the generalized weighted GAN and the generator impact GAN, both aim at reducing the impact of the generator on the discriminator, so both can learn more gradually and efficiently during training. Applying an energy constraint to the cycleGAN paradigm considerably improved conversion quality. A subjective experiment conducted on a voice conversion task on t…
Mel-frequency filter bank (MFB) based approaches have the advantage of learning speech compared to raw spectrum since MFB has less feature size. However, speech generator with MFB approaches require additional vocoder that needs a huge amount of computation expense for training process. The additional pre/post processing such as MFB and vocoder is not essential to convert real human speech to others. It is possible to only use the raw spectrum along with the phase to generate different style of voices with clear pronunciation. In this regard, we propose a fast and effective approach to convert…
Recently, voice conversion (VC) without parallel data has been successfully adapted to multi-target scenario in which a single model is trained to convert the input voice to many different speakers. However, such model suffers from the limitation that it can only convert the voice to the speakers in the training data, which narrows down the applicable scenario of VC. In this paper, we proposed a novel one-shot VC approach which is able to perform VC by only an example utterance from source and target speaker respectively, and the source and target speaker do not even need to be seen during tra…
Here we present a novel approach to conditioning the SampleRNN generative model for voice conversion (VC). Conventional methods for VC modify the perceived speaker identity by converting between source and target acoustic features. Our approach focuses on preserving voice content and depends on the generative network to learn voice style. We first train a multi-speaker SampleRNN model conditioned on linguistic features, pitch contour, and speaker identity using a multi-speaker speech corpus. Voice-converted speech is generated using linguistic features and pitch contour extracted from the sour…
Traditional voice conversion methods rely on parallel recordings of multiple speakers pronouncing the same sentences. For real-world applications however, parallel data is rarely available. We propose MelGAN-VC, a voice conversion method that relies on non-parallel speech data and is able to convert audio signals of arbitrary length from a source voice to a target voice. We firstly compute spectrograms from waveform data and then perform a domain translation using a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) architecture. An additional siamese network helps preserving speech information in the trans…
Any-to-any voice conversion technologies convert the vocal timbre of an utterance to any speaker even unseen during training. Although there have been several state-of-the-art any-to-any voice conversion models, they were all based on clean utterances to convert successfully. However, in real-world scenarios, it is difficult to collect clean utterances of a speaker, and they are usually degraded by noises or reverberations. It thus becomes highly desired to understand how these degradations affect voice conversion and build a degradation-robust model. We report in this paper the first comprehe…
Voice conversion is a common speech synthesis task which can be solved in different ways depending on a particular real-world scenario. The most challenging one often referred to as one-shot many-to-many voice conversion consists in copying the target voice from only one reference utterance in the most general case when both source and target speakers do not belong to the training dataset. We present a scalable high-quality solution based on diffusion probabilistic modeling and demonstrate its superior quality compared to state-of-the-art one-shot voice conversion approaches. Moreover, focusin…
Institute of Acoustics, Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院声学研究所）；University of Chinese Academy of Sciences（中国科学院大学）
Voice conversion models have developed for decades, and current mainstream research focuses on non-streaming voice conversion. However, streaming voice conversion is more suitable for practical application scenarios than non-streaming voice conversion. In this paper, we propose a streaming any-to-many voice conversion based on fully non-autoregressive model, which includes a streaming transformer based acoustic model and a streaming vocoder. Streaming transformer based acoustic model is composed of a pre-trained encoder from streaming end-to-end based automatic speech recognition model and a d…
Singapore University of Technology and Design（新加坡科技设计大学）；National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；University of Edinburgh（爱丁堡大学）；National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）
Speaker identity is one of the important characteristics of human speech. In voice conversion, we change the speaker identity from one to another, while keeping the linguistic content unchanged. Voice conversion involves multiple speech processing techniques, such as speech analysis, spectral conversion, prosody conversion, speaker characterization, and vocoding. With the recent advances in theory and practice, we are now able to produce human-like voice quality with high speaker similarity. In this paper, we provide a comprehensive overview of the state-of-the-art of voice conversion techniqu…
Logitech Europe S.A.（罗技欧洲公司）；École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL)（洛桑联邦理工学院（EPFL））
This paper presents AC-VC (Almost Causal Voice Conversion), a phonetic posteriorgrams based voice conversion system that can perform any-to-many voice conversion while having only 57.5 ms future look-ahead. The complete system is composed of three neural networks trained separately with non-parallel data. While most of the current voice conversion systems focus primarily on quality irrespective of algorithmic latency, this work elaborates on designing a method using a minimal amount of future context thus allowing a future real-time implementation. According to a subjective listening test orga…
Conventional singing voice conversion (SVC) methods often suffer from operating in high-resolution audio owing to a high dimensionality of data. In this paper, we propose a hierarchical representation learning that enables the learning of disentangled representations with multiple resolutions independently. With the learned disentangled representations, the proposed method progressively performs SVC from low to high resolutions. Experimental results show that the proposed method outperforms baselines that operate with a single resolution in terms of mean opinion score (MOS), similarity score, …
Recently, more and more zero-shot voice conversion algorithms have been proposed. As a fundamental part of zero-shot voice conversion, speaker embeddings are the key to improving the converted speech's speaker similarity. In this paper, we study the impact of speaker embeddings on zero-shot voice conversion performance. To better represent the characteristics of the target speaker and improve the speaker similarity in zero-shot voice conversion, we propose a novel speaker representation method in this paper. Our method combines the advantages of D-vector, global style token (GST) based speaker…
Voice conversion (VC) is a task that transforms voice from target audio to source without losing linguistic contents, it is challenging especially when source and target speakers are unseen during training (zero-shot VC). Previous approaches require a pre-trained model or linguistic data to do the zero-shot conversion. Meanwhile, VC models with Vector Quantization (VQ) or Instance Normalization (IN) are able to disentangle contents from audios and achieve successful conversions. However, disentanglement in these models highly relies on heavily constrained bottleneck layers, thus, the sound qua…
Cycle consistent generative adversarial network (CycleGAN) and variational autoencoder (VAE) based models have gained popularity in non-parallel voice conversion recently. However, they often suffer from difficult training process and unsatisfactory results. In this paper, we propose CVC, a contrastive learning-based adversarial approach for voice conversion. Compared to previous CycleGAN-based methods, CVC only requires an efficient one-way GAN training by taking the advantage of contrastive learning. When it comes to non-parallel one-to-one voice conversion, CVC is on par or better than Cycl…
Cross-lingual voice conversion (VC) is a task that aims to synthesize target voices with the same content while source and target speakers speak in different languages. Its challenge lies in the fact that the source and target data are naturally non-parallel, and it is even difficult to bridge the gaps between languages with no transcriptions provided. In this paper, we focus on knowledge transfer from monolin-gual ASR to cross-lingual VC, in order to address the con-tent mismatch problem. To achieve this, we first train a monolingual acoustic model for the source language, use it to extract p…
This paper introduces Taco-VC, a novel architecture for voice conversion based on Tacotron synthesizer, which is a sequence-to-sequence with attention model. The training of multi-speaker voice conversion systems requires a large number of resources, both in training and corpus size. Taco-VC is implemented using a single speaker Tacotron synthesizer based on Phonetic PosteriorGrams (PPGs) and a single speaker WaveNet vocoder conditioned on mel spectrograms. To enhance the converted speech quality, and to overcome over-smoothing, the outputs of Tacotron are passed through a novel speechenhancem…
Singing voice conversion is converting the timbre in the source singing to the target speaker's voice while keeping singing content the same. However, singing data for target speaker is much more difficult to collect compared with normal speech data.In this paper, we introduce a singing voice conversion algorithm that is capable of generating high quality target speaker's singing using only his/her normal speech data. First, we manage to integrate the training and conversion process of speech and singing into one framework by unifying the features used in standard speech synthesis system and s…
NTT Communication Science Laboratories（NTT通信科学实验室）
Voice conversion is a task to convert a non-linguistic feature of a given utterance. Since naturalness of speech strongly depends on its pitch pattern, in some applications, it would be desirable to keep the original rise/fall pitch pattern while changing the speaker identity. Some of the existing methods address this problem by either using a source-filter model or developing a neural network that takes an F0 pattern as input to the model. Although the latter approach can achieve relatively high sound quality compared to the former one, there is no consideration for discrepancy between the ta…
Southeast University（东南大学）；National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）
This paper presents a novel framework to build a voice conversion (VC) system by learning from a text-to-speech (TTS) synthesis system, that is called TTS-VC transfer learning. We first develop a multi-speaker speech synthesis system with sequence-to-sequence encoder-decoder architecture, where the encoder extracts robust linguistic representations of text, and the decoder, conditioned on target speaker embedding, takes the context vectors and the attention recurrent network cell output to generate target acoustic features. We take advantage of the fact that TTS system maps input text to speak…
Ping An Technology (Shenzhen) Co., Ltd.（平安科技（深圳）有限公司）；University of Science and Technology of China（中国科学技术大学）
Voice Conversion(VC) refers to changing the timbre of a speech while retaining the discourse content. Recently, many works have focused on disentangle-based learning techniques to separate the timbre and the linguistic content information from a speech signal. Once successful, voice conversion will be feasible and straightforward. This paper proposed a novel one-shot voice conversion framework based on vector quantization voice conversion (VQVC) and AutoVC, called AVQVC. A new training method is applied to VQVC to separate content and timbre information from speech more effectively. The result…
1 Universitat Polit\`ecnica de Catalunya, Barcelona, Spain 2 Telef\'onica Research, Barcelona, Spain 3 Universidad de M\'alaga, M\'alaga, Spain
Most methods of voice restoration for patients suffering from aphonia either produce whispered or monotone speech. Apart from intelligibility, this type of speech lacks expressiveness and naturalness due to the absence of pitch (whispered speech) or artificial generation of it (monotone speech). Existing techniques to restore prosodic information typically combine a vocoder, which parameterises the speech signal, with machine learning techniques that predict prosodic information. In contrast, this paper describes an end-to-end neural approach for estimating a fully-voiced speech waveform from …
This paper presents the IQIYI voice conversion system (T24) for Voice Conversion 2020. In the competition, each target speaker has 70 sentences. We have built an end-to-end voice conversion system based on PPG. First, the ASR acoustic model calculates the BN feature, which represents the content-related information in the speech. Then the Mel feature is calculated through an improved prosody tacotron model. Finally, the Mel spectrum is converted to wav through an improved LPCNet. The evaluation results show that this system can achieve better voice conversion effects. In the case of using 16k …
In this paper, we present the voice conversion (VC) systems developed at Nagoya University (NU) for the Voice Conversion Challenge 2020 (VCC2020). We aim to determine the effectiveness of two recent significant technologies in VC: sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) models and autoregressive (AR) neural vocoders. Two respective systems were developed for the two tasks in the challenge: for task 1, we adopted the Voice Transformer Network, a Transformer-based seq2seq VC model, and extended it with synthetic parallel data to tackle nonparallel data; for task 2, we used the frame-based cyclic variatio…
A Comparative Study of Voice Conversion Models with Large-Scale Speech and Singing Data: The T13 Systems for the Singing Voice Conversion Challenge 2023
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) needs to be robust to speaker differences. Voice Conversion (VC) modifies speaker characteristics of input speech. This is an attractive feature for ASR data augmentation. In this paper, we demonstrate that voice conversion can be used as a data augmentation technique to improve ASR performance, even on LibriSpeech, which contains 2,456 speakers. For ASR augmentation, it is necessary that the VC model be robust to a wide range of input speech. This motivates the use of a non-autoregressive, non-parallel VC model, and the use of a pretrained ASR encoder within…
Northwestern Polytechnical University（西北工业大学）；National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）
We propose a novel training scheme to optimize voice conversion network with a speaker identity loss function. The training scheme not only minimizes frame-level spectral loss, but also speaker identity loss. We introduce a cycle consistency loss that constrains the converted speech to maintain the same speaker identity as reference speech at utterance level. While the proposed training scheme is applicable to any voice conversion networks, we formulate the study under the average model voice conversion framework in this paper. Experiments conducted on CMU-ARCTIC and CSTR-VCTK corpus confirm t…
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign（伊利诺伊大学厄巴纳-香槟分校）；MIT-IBM Watson AI Lab（麻省理工学院-IBM沃森人工智能实验室）
SpeechSplit can perform aspect-specific voice conversion by disentangling speech into content, rhythm, pitch, and timbre using multiple autoencoders in an unsupervised manner. However, SpeechSplit requires careful tuning of the autoencoder bottlenecks, which can be time-consuming and less robust. This paper proposes SpeechSplit 2.0, which constrains the information flow of the speech component to be disentangled on the autoencoder input using efficient signal processing methods instead of bottleneck tuning. Evaluation results show that SpeechSplit 2.0 achieves comparable performance to SpeechS…
We propose a novel architecture and improved training objectives for non-parallel voice conversion. Our proposed CycleGAN-based model performs a shape-preserving transformation directly on a high frequency-resolution magnitude spectrogram, converting its style (i.e. speaker identity) while preserving the speech content. Throughout the entire conversion process, the model does not resort to compressed intermediate representations of any sort (e.g. mel spectrogram, low resolution spectrogram, decomposed network feature). We propose an efficient axial residual block architecture to support this e…
This paper describes the Academia Sinica systems for the two tasks of Voice Conversion Challenge 2020, namely voice conversion within the same language (Task 1) and cross-lingual voice conversion (Task 2). For both tasks, we followed the cascaded ASR+TTS structure, using phonetic tokens as the TTS input instead of the text or characters. For Task 1, we used the international phonetic alphabet (IPA) as the input of the TTS model. For Task 2, we used unsupervised phonetic symbols extracted by the vector-quantized variational autoencoder (VQVAE). In the evaluation, the listening test showed that …
In this work, we propose a zero-shot voice conversion method using speech representations trained with self-supervised learning. First, we develop a multi-task model to decompose a speech utterance into features such as linguistic content, speaker characteristics, and speaking style. To disentangle content and speaker representations, we propose a training strategy based on Siamese networks that encourages similarity between the content representations of the original and pitch-shifted audio. Next, we develop a synthesis model with pitch and duration predictors that can effectively reconstruct…
MINDsLab Inc.（MINDsLab公司）；Seoul National University（首尔国立大学）
Recent works on voice conversion (VC) focus on preserving the rhythm and the intonation as well as the linguistic content. To preserve these features from the source, we decompose current non-parallel VC systems into two encoders and one decoder. We analyze each module with several experiments and reassemble the best components to propose Assem-VC, a new state-of-the-art any-to-many non-parallel VC system. We also examine that PPG and Cotatron features are speaker-dependent, and attempt to remove speaker identity with adversarial training. Code and audio samples are available at https://github…
College of Electrical Engineering（电气工程学院）；Computer Science, National Taiwan University, Taiwan（台湾大学计算机科学系）
Voice conversion technologies have been greatly improved in recent years with the help of deep learning, but their capabilities of producing natural sounding utterances in different conditions remain unclear. In this paper, we gave a thorough study of the robustness of known VC models. We also modified these models, such as the replacement of speaker embeddings, to further improve their performances. We found that the sampling rate and audio duration greatly influence voice conversion. All the VC models suffer from unseen data, but AdaIN-VC is relatively more robust. Also, the speaker embeddin…
National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）；Singapore University of Technology and Design（新加坡科技设计大学）
Cross-lingual voice conversion aims to change source speaker's voice to sound like that of target speaker, when source and target speakers speak different languages. It relies on non-parallel training data from two different languages, hence, is more challenging than mono-lingual voice conversion. Previous studies on cross-lingual voice conversion mainly focus on spectral conversion with a linear transformation for F0 transfer. However, as an important prosodic factor, F0 is inherently hierarchical, thus it is insufficient to just use a linear method for conversion. We propose the use of conti…
National Institute of Technology Durgapur（杜尔加布尔国立理工学院）；Indian Statistical Institute（印度统计研究所）
Voice Conversion (VC) emerged as a significant domain of research in the field of speech synthesis in recent years due to its emerging application in voice-assisting technology, automated movie dubbing, and speech-to-singing conversion to name a few. VC basically deals with the conversion of vocal style of one speaker to another speaker while keeping the linguistic contents unchanged. VC task is performed through a three-stage pipeline consisting of speech analysis, speech feature mapping, and speech reconstruction. Nowadays the Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) models are widely in use for…
Voice conversion has gained increasing popularity in many applications of speech synthesis. The idea is to change the voice identity from one speaker into another while keeping the linguistic content unchanged. Many voice conversion approaches rely on the use of a vocoder to reconstruct the speech from acoustic features, and as a consequence, the speech quality heavily depends on such a vocoder. In this paper, we propose NVC-Net, an end-to-end adversarial network, which performs voice conversion directly on the raw audio waveform of arbitrary length. By disentangling the speaker identity from …
National Institute of Informatics（国立信息学研究所）；Nagoya University（名古屋大学）；National University of Singapore（新加坡国立大学）；University of Eastern Finland（东芬兰大学）；University of Science and Technology of China（中国科学技术大学）
The voice conversion challenge is a bi-annual scientific event held to compare and understand different voice conversion (VC) systems built on a common dataset. In 2020, we organized the third edition of the challenge and constructed and distributed a new database for two tasks, intra-lingual semi-parallel and cross-lingual VC. After a two-month challenge period, we received 33 submissions, including 3 baselines built on the database. From the results of crowd-sourced listening tests, we observed that VC methods have progressed rapidly thanks to advanced deep learning methods. In particular, s…
