arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2002.12464physics.soc-phcs.GTcs.SIq-bio.PE
收藏

“做正确的事”是为了谁?群体内偏好、群体分类与道德支持的实验研究

"Do the Right Thing" for Whom? An Experiment on Ingroup Favouritism, Group Assorting and Moral Suasion

Ennio Bilancini, Leonardo Boncinelli, Valerio Capraro, Tatiana Celadin, Roberto Di Paolo

摘要:

本文考察了道德支持对群体内偏好的影响。我们报告一个良好的动力,预注册,两阶段2x2混合设计实验。在第一阶段,小组是根据参与者如何回答一组问题而形成的,这些问题涉及一种治疗中的非道德相关问题(非道德偏好的验证)和另一种治疗中的道德相关问题(道德偏好的验证)。在第二阶段,参与者选择如何在自己组的参与者和另一组的参与者之间分配一定数量的钱,首先在基线设置中,然后在他们被告知做他们认为道德上正确的事情的设置中(道德支持)。我们的主要结果是:(i)在基线中,与根据非道德偏好进行分类相比,当群体根据道德偏好进行分类时,参与者倾向于更大程度地偏袒自己的群体;(ii)道德支持的净效应是减少群体内偏袒,但也有不可忽略的参与者比例,道德支持增加了群体内偏袒;(iii)道德支持的效果在群体认同和四个预先登记的个人特征(性别、政治取向、宗教信仰、支持生命与支持选择的道德信念)中基本稳定。

英文摘要:

In this paper we investigate the effect of moral suasion on ingroup favouritism. We report a well-powered, pre-registered, two-stage 2x2 mixed-design experiment. In the first stage, groups are formed on the basis of how participants answer to a set of questions, concerning non-morally relevant issues in one treatment (assorting on non-moral preferences), and morally relevant issues in another treatment (assorting on moral preferences). In the second stage, participants choose how to split a given amount of money between participants of their own group and participants of the other group, first in the baseline setting and then in a setting where they are told to do what they believe to be morally right (moral suasion). Our main results are: (i) in the baseline, participants tend to favour their own group to a greater extent when groups are assorted according to moral preferences, compared to when they are assorted according to non-moral preferences; (ii) the net effect of moral suasion is to decrease ingroup favouritism, but there is also a non-negligible proportion of participants for whom moral suasion increases ingroup favouritism; (iii) the effect of moral suasion is substantially stable across group assorting and four pre-registered individual characteristics (gender, political orientation, religiosity, pro-life vs pro-choice ethical convictions).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑