arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 2002.05746stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

中断时间序列设计的仿真分析

Using Simulation to Analyze Interrupted Time Series Designs

Luke Miratrix

摘要:

我们有时被迫使用中断时间序列(ITS)设计作为潜在政策变化的识别策略,例如当我们只有一个单一的治疗单位,没有可比的控制。例如,随着最近全国范围的刑事司法改革努力,司法机构改变了其管辖范围内每个人的保释设置做法,以减少审前拘留率,同时维护法院秩序和公共安全,我们没有自然的比较组比过去。在这些背景下,必须对政策前趋势进行轻度建模,考虑到自回归偏离任何预先存在的趋势等结构,以便准确和现实地评估我们预测的统计不确定性(超出后续因果推断所需的严格假设)。为了解决这个问题,我们提供了一种方法学方法,这种方法植根于通常理解和使用的建模方法,可以更好地捕捉不确定性。我们量化的不确定性与模拟,生成一个分布的似是而非的反事实的轨迹比较观察到的,这种方法自然允许将季节性和其他随时间变化的协变量,并提供置信区间随着点估计的政策变化的潜在影响。我们发现模拟提供了一个自然的框架来捕捉和显示ITS设计中的不确定性。它还允许简单的扩展,如非参数平滑,以处理多个政策后时间点或更多的结构模型,以考虑季节性。

英文摘要:

We are sometimes forced to use the Interrupted Time Series (ITS) design as an identification strategy for potential policy change, such as when we only have a single treated unit and no comparable controls. For example, with recent county- and state-wide criminal justice reform efforts, where judicial bodies have changed bail setting practices for everyone in their jurisdiction in order to reduce rates of pre-trial detention while maintaining court order and public safety, we have no natural comparison group other than the past. In these contexts, it is imperative to model pre-policy trends with a light touch, allowing for structures such as autoregressive departures from any pre-existing trend, in order to accurately and realistically assess the statistical uncertainty of our projections (beyond the stringent assumptions necessary for the subsequent causal inferences). To tackle this problem we provide a methodological approach rooted in commonly understood and used modeling approaches that better captures uncertainty. We quantify uncertainty with simulation, generating a distribution of plausible counterfactual trajectories to compare to the observed; this approach naturally allows for incorporating seasonality and other time varying covariates, and provides confidence intervals along with point estimates for the potential impacts of policy change. We find simulation provides a natural framework to capture and show uncertainty in the ITS designs. It also allows for easy extensions such as nonparametric smoothing in order to handle multiple post-policy time points or more structural models to account for seasonality.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑