arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 2002.02793cs.SE
收藏

学术和实践中的质量要求观:共同点,差异和背景相关的灰色区域

Views on Quality Requirements in Academia and Practice: Commonalities, Differences, and Context-Dependent Grey Areas

Andreas Vogelsang, Jonas Eckhardt, Daniel Mendez, Moritz Berger

摘要:

背景:质量要求(QR)是工业界和学术界不断讨论的话题。争论围绕质量要求的定义,如何处理它们,或者它们对项目成功的重要性。虽然许多学术努力对QR的知识体系做出了贡献,但实践者可能有不同的观点。事实上,我们仍然缺乏关于QR的一致的知识体系,因为围绕这个主题的大部分讨论仍然被强烈依赖于上下文的观察所主导。这对学术界和实践者的观点都适用。我们的假设是,因此,这些观点可能不同。目的:我们报告的一项研究,以更好地了解在何种程度上可用的研究声明的质量要求,发现在示范同行评审和经常引用的出版物,反映在从业者的看法。我们的目标是分析差异,共性和背景相关的灰色地带,在学者和从业者的观点,允许对潜在的误解(双方)和未来研究的机会进行讨论。方法:我们进行了一项调查,109从业者,以评估他们是否同意研究声明中反映的QR码在文献中。基于一个统计模型,我们评估了一组上下文因素对研究陈述感知的影响。结果:我们的研究结果表明,大多数的声明是由从业人员很好的尊重,但不是所有的。在研究不同群体和背景的受访者时,我们注意到不同群体内的看法存在有趣的偏差,这可能会导致新的研究问题。结论:我们的研究结果有助于确定普遍的上下文相关的差异,学者和从业者如何看待QR码和精确定位的声明,进一步的研究可能是有用的。

英文摘要:

Context: Quality requirements (QRs) are a topic of constant discussions both in industry and academia. Debates entwine around the definition of quality requirements, the way how to handle them, or their importance for project success. While many academic endeavors contribute to the body of knowledge about QRs, practitioners may have different views. In fact, we still lack a consistent body of knowledge on QRs since much of the discussion around this topic is still dominated by observations that are strongly context-dependent. This holds for both academic and practitioners' views. Our assumption is that, in consequence, those views may differ. Objective: We report on a study to better understand the extent to which available research statements on quality requirements, as found in exemplary peer-reviewed and frequently cited publications, are reflected in the perception of practitioners. Our goal is to analyze differences, commonalities, and context-dependent grey areas in the views of academics and practitioners to allow a discussion on potential misconceptions (on either sides) and opportunities for future research. Method: We conducted a survey with 109 practitioners to assess whether they agree with research statements about QRs reflected in the literature. Based on a statistical model, we evaluate the impact of a set of context factors to the perception of research statements. Results: Our results show that a majority of the statements is well respected by practitioners; however, not all of them. When examining the different groups and backgrounds of respondents, we noticed interesting deviations of perceptions within different groups that may lead to new research questions. Conclusions: Our results help identifying prevalent context-dependent differences about how academics and practitioners view QRs and pinpointing statements where further research might be useful.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑