arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1910.13347stat.OTstat.AP
收藏

跳球、评分下降和精英地位:三个四分卫评分统计的敏感性分析

Jump balls, rating falls, and elite status: A sensitivity analysis of three quarterback rating statistics

Laura A. Albert, John N. Angelis

摘要:

四分卫的表现可能很难排名,许多努力已经花在创建新的评级系统。然而,这种评级的输入统计数据受到随机性和四分卫控制之外的因素的影响。为了研究这种差异,我们对三个四分卫评级统计数据进行了敏感性分析:史密斯1971年的传统评级,伯克和胜利的工资评级。这些比较是在2002-2015年的32支NFL球队的球队层面上进行的,因此每支球队都有16场比赛。我们计算每一次进攻的四分卫评分,增加1-5次触地得分,减少1-5次拦截,增加1-5次麻袋,增加1- 5%的传球完成率。我们的敏感性分析根据随机结果提供了对精英传球队是否看起来平庸或反之亦然的洞察。结果表明,传统的评级是最敏感的统计方面的触地得分,拦截和完成,而伯克评级是最敏感的麻袋。分析表明,球队传球进攻排名对四分卫无法控制的足球方面高度敏感(例如,导致拦截的偏离传球)。因此,在边际上,我们表明关于一个特定的四分卫是否已经进入精英或仍然平庸的争论是无关紧要的。

英文摘要:

Quarterback performance can be difficult to rank, and much effort has been spent in creating new rating systems. However, the input statistics for such ratings are subject to randomness and factors outside the quarterback's control. To investigate this variance, we perform a sensitivity analysis of three quarterback rating statistics: the Traditional 1971 rating by Smith, the Burke, and the Wages of Wins ratings. The comparisons are made at the team level for the 32 NFL teams from 2002-2015, thus giving each case an even 16 games. We compute quarterback ratings for each offense with 1-5 additional touchdowns, 1-5 fewer interceptions, 1-5 additional sacks, and a 1-5 percent increase in the passing completion rate. Our sensitivity analysis provides insight into whether an elite passing team could seem mediocre or vice versa based on random outcomes. The results indicate that the Traditional rating is the most sensitive statistic with respect to touchdowns, interceptions, and completions, whereas the Burke rating is most sensitive to sacks. The analysis suggests that team passing offense rankings are highly sensitive to aspects of football that are out of the quarterback's hands (e.g., deflected passes that lead to interceptions). Thus, on the margins, we show arguments about whether a specific quarterback has entered the elite or remains mediocre are irrelevant.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑