Bayesian Temporal Factorization for Multidimensional Time Series Prediction
Polytechnique Montreal(蒙特利尔综合理工学院);McGill University(麦吉尔大学);Interuniversity Research Centre on Enterprise Networks, Logistics and Transportation (CIRRELT)(校际企业网络、物流与交通研究中心(CIRRELT))
Large-scale and multidimensional spatiotemporal data sets are becoming ubiquitous in many real-world applications such as monitoring urban traffic and air quality. Making predictions on these time series has become a critical challenge due to not only the large-scale and high-dimensional nature but also the considerable amount of missing data. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian temporal factorization (BTF) framework for modeling multidimensional time series -- in particular spatiotemporal data -- in the presence of missing values. By integrating low-rank matrix/tensor factorization and vector autoregressive (VAR) process into a single probabilistic graphical model, this framework can characterize both global and local consistencies in large-scale time series data. The graphical model allows us to effectively perform probabilistic predictions and produce uncertainty estimates without imputing those missing values. We develop efficient Gibbs sampling algorithms for model inference and model updating for real-time prediction and test the proposed BTF framework on several real-world spatiotemporal data sets for both missing data imputation and multi-step rolling prediction tasks. The numerical experiments demonstrate the superiority of the proposed BTF approaches over existing state-of-the-art methods.
This work explores non-negative low-rank matrix factorization based on regularized Poisson models (PF or "Poisson factorization" for short) for recommender systems with implicit-feedback data. The properties of Poisson likelihood allow a shortcut for very fast computations over zero-valued inputs, and oftentimes results in very sparse factors for both users and items. Compared to HPF (a popular Bayesian formulation of the problem with hierarchical priors), the frequentist optimization-based approach presented here tends to produce better top-N recommendations with significantly shorter fitting…
We propose a generative model of a group EEG analysis, based on appropriate kernel assumptions on EEG data. We derive the variational inference update rule using various approximation techniques. The proposed model outperforms the current state-of-the-art algorithms in terms of common pattern extraction. The validity of the proposed model is tested on the BCI competition dataset.
University of Washington(华盛顿大学);Carnegie Mellon University(卡内基梅隆大学)
Relational learning can be used to augment one data source with other correlated sources of information, to improve predictive accuracy. We frame a large class of relational learning problems as matrix factorization problems, and propose a hierarchical Bayesian model. Training our Bayesian model using random-walk Metropolis-Hastings is impractically slow, and so we develop a block Metropolis-Hastings sampler which uses the gradient and Hessian of the likelihood to dynamically tune the proposal. We demonstrate that a predictive model of brain response to stimuli can be improved by augmenting it…
University of California, Irvine(加州大学尔湾分校);Google(谷歌);Yahoo Labs(雅虎实验室);University of Amsterdam(阿姆斯特丹大学)
Despite having various attractive qualities such as high prediction accuracy and the ability to quantify uncertainty and avoid over-fitting, Bayesian Matrix Factorization has not been widely adopted because of the prohibitive cost of inference. In this paper, we propose a scalable distributed Bayesian matrix factorization algorithm using stochastic gradient MCMC. Our algorithm, based on Distributed Stochastic Gradient Langevin Dynamics, can not only match the prediction accuracy of standard MCMC methods like Gibbs sampling, but at the same time is as fast and simple as stochastic gradient desc…
Bayesian low-rank matrix factorization techniques have become an essential tool for relational data analysis and matrix completion. A standard approach is to assign zero-mean Gaussian priors on the columns or rows of factor matrices to create a conjugate system. This choice of prior leads to simple implementations; however it also causes symmetries in the posterior distribution that can severely reduce the efficiency of Markov-chain Monte-Carlo (MCMC) sampling approaches. In this paper, we propose a simple modification to the prior choice that provably breaks these symmetries and maintains/imp…
Department of Mathematics, UC Santa Barbara(加州大学圣巴巴拉分校数学系);Department of ECE, UC Santa Barbara(加州大学圣巴巴拉分校电气工程与计算机科学系)
Streaming tensor factorization is a powerful tool for processing high-volume and multi-way temporal data in Internet networks, recommender systems and image/video data analysis. Existing streaming tensor factorization algorithms rely on least-squares data fitting and they do not possess a mechanism for tensor rank determination. This leaves them susceptible to outliers and vulnerable to over-fitting. This paper presents a Bayesian robust streaming tensor factorization model to identify sparse outliers, automatically determine the underlying tensor rank and accurately fit low-rank structure. We…
In this work, we empirically explore the question: how can we assess the quality of samples from some target distribution? We assume that the samples are provided by some valid Monte Carlo procedure, so we are guaranteed that the collection of samples will asymptotically approximate the true distribution. Most current evaluation approaches focus on two questions: (1) Has the chain mixed, that is, is it sampling from the distribution? and (2) How independent are the samples (as MCMC procedures produce correlated samples)? Focusing on the case of Bayesian nonnegative matrix factorization, we emp…
We present a Bayesian non-negative tensor factorization model for count-valued tensor data, and develop scalable inference algorithms (both batch and online) for dealing with massive tensors. Our generative model can handle overdispersed counts as well as infer the rank of the decomposition. Moreover, leveraging a reparameterization of the Poisson distribution as a multinomial facilitates conjugacy in the model and enables simple and efficient Gibbs sampling and variational Bayes (VB) inference updates, with a computational cost that only depends on the number of nonzeros in the tensor. The mo…
imec(比利时微电子研究中心);Helsinki Institute for Information Technology (HIIT)(赫尔辛基信息技术研究所(HIIT));Aalto University(阿尔托大学)
Matrix factorization is a very common machine learning technique in recommender systems. Bayesian Matrix Factorization (BMF) algorithms would be attractive because of their ability to quantify uncertainty in their predictions and avoid over-fitting, combined with high prediction accuracy. However, they have not been widely used on large-scale data because of their prohibitive computational cost. In recent work, efforts have been made to reduce the cost, both by improving the scalability of the BMF algorithm as well as its implementation, but so far mainly separately. In this paper we show that…
Criteo AI Lab(Criteo人工智能实验室);IRIT(图卢兹计算机科学研究所);Université de Toulouse(图卢兹大学);CNRS(法国国家科学研究中心)
Binary data matrices can represent many types of data such as social networks, votes, or gene expression. In some cases, the analysis of binary matrices can be tackled with nonnegative matrix factorization (NMF), where the observed data matrix is approximated by the product of two smaller nonnegative matrices. In this context, probabilistic NMF assumes a generative model where the data is usually Bernoulli-distributed. Often, a link function is used to map the factorization to the $[0,1]$ range, ensuring a valid Bernoulli mean parameter. However, link functions have the potential disadvantage …
Non-negative tensor factorization models enable predictive analysis on count data. Among them, Bayesian Poisson-Gamma models can derive full posterior distributions of latent factors and are less sensitive to sparse count data. However, current inference methods for these Bayesian models adopt restricted update rules for the posterior parameters. They also fail to share the update information to better cope with the data sparsity. Moreover, these models are not endowed with a component that handles the imbalance in count data values. In this paper, we propose a novel variational auto-encoder f…
In this paper, we introduce a probabilistic model for learning nonnegative matrix factorization (NMF) that is commonly used for predicting missing values and finding hidden patterns in the data, in which the matrix factors are latent variables associated with each data dimension. The nonnegativity constraint for the latent factors is handled by choosing priors with support on the nonnegative subspace. Bayesian inference procedure based on Gibbs sampling is employed. We evaluate the model on several real-world datasets including MovieLens 100K and MovieLens 1M with different sizes and dimension…
Non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) is a new knowledge discovery method that is used for text mining, signal processing, bioinformatics, and consumer analysis. However, its basic property as a learning machine is not yet clarified, as it is not a regular statistical model, resulting that theoretical optimization method of NMF has not yet established. In this paper, we study the real log canonical threshold of NMF and give an upper bound of the generalization error in Bayesian learning. The results show that the generalization error of the matrix factorization can be made smaller than regul…
We propose a simulation method for multidimensional Hawkes processes based on superposition theory of point processes. This formulation allows us to design efficient simulations for Hawkes processes with differing exponentially decaying intensities. We demonstrate that inter-arrival times can be decomposed into simpler auxiliary variables that can be sampled directly, giving exact simulation with no approximation. We establish that the auxiliary variables provides information on the parent process for each event time. The algorithm correctness is shown by verifying the simulated intensities wi…
Nonnegative matrix factorization (NMF) with group sparsity constraints is formulated as a probabilistic graphical model and, assuming some observed data have been generated by the model, a feasible variational Bayesian algorithm is derived for learning model parameters. When used in a supervised learning scenario, NMF is most often utilized as an unsupervised feature extractor followed by classification in the obtained feature subspace. Having mapped the class labels to a more general concept of groups which underlie sparsity of the coefficients, what the proposed group sparse NMF model allows…
We introduce a probabilistic model with implicit norm regularization for learning nonnegative matrix factorization (NMF) that is commonly used for predicting missing values and finding hidden patterns in the data, in which the matrix factors are latent variables associated with each data dimension. The nonnegativity constraint for the latent factors is handled by choosing priors with support on the nonnegative subspace, e.g., exponential density or distribution based on exponential function. Bayesian inference procedure based on Gibbs sampling is employed. We evaluate the model on several real…
CANDECOMP/PARAFAC (CP) tensor factorization of incomplete data is a powerful technique for tensor completion through explicitly capturing the multilinear latent factors. The existing CP algorithms require the tensor rank to be manually specified, however, the determination of tensor rank remains a challenging problem especially for CP rank. In addition, existing approaches do not take into account uncertainty information of latent factors, as well as missing entries. To address these issues, we formulate CP factorization using a hierarchical probabilistic model and employ a fully Bayesian trea…
University of Massachusetts Amherst(马萨诸塞大学阿默斯特分校);Columbia University(哥伦比亚大学);Microsoft Research(微软研究院)
We present a Bayesian tensor factorization model for inferring latent group structures from dynamic pairwise interaction patterns. For decades, political scientists have collected and analyzed records of the form "country $i$ took action $a$ toward country $j$ at time $t$"---known as dyadic events---in order to form and test theories of international relations. We represent these event data as a tensor of counts and develop Bayesian Poisson tensor factorization to infer a low-dimensional, interpretable representation of their salient patterns. We demonstrate that our model's predictive perform…
Columbia University(哥伦比亚大学);Adobe Research(Adobe研究院);Adobe Systems Incorporated(奥多比系统公司)
Beta process is the standard nonparametric Bayesian prior for latent factor model. In this paper, we derive a structured mean-field variational inference algorithm for a beta process non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) model with Poisson likelihood. Unlike the linear Gaussian model, which is well-studied in the nonparametric Bayesian literature, NMF model with beta process prior does not enjoy the conjugacy. We leverage the recently developed stochastic structured mean-field variational inference to relax the conjugacy constraint and restore the dependencies among the latent variables in t…
NTT DATA Mathematical Systems Inc.(NTT数据数学系统公司);Tokyo Institute of Technology(东京工业大学)
Non-negative matrix factorization (NMF) is a knowledge discovery method that is used in many fields. Variational inference and Gibbs sampling methods for it are also wellknown. However, the variational approximation error has not been clarified yet, because NMF is not statistically regular and the prior distribution used in variational Bayesian NMF (VBNMF) has zero or divergence points. In this paper, using algebraic geometrical methods, we theoretically analyze the difference in negative log evidence (a.k.a. free energy) between VBNMF and Bayesian NMF, i.e., the Kullback-Leibler divergence be…
The vast majority of current machine learning algorithms are designed to predict single responses or a vector of responses, yet many types of response are more naturally organized as matrices or higher-order tensor objects where characteristics are shared across modes. We present a new machine learning algorithm BaTFLED (Bayesian Tensor Factorization Linked to External Data) that predicts values in a three-dimensional response tensor using input features for each of the dimensions. BaTFLED uses a probabilistic Bayesian framework to learn projection matrices mapping input features for each mode…
Bayesian Matrix Factorization (BMF) is a powerful technique for recommender systems because it produces good results and is relatively robust against overfitting. Yet BMF is more computationally intensive and thus more challenging to implement for large datasets. In this work we present SMURFF a high-performance feature-rich framework to compose and construct different Bayesian matrix-factorization methods. The framework has been successfully used in to do large scale runs of compound-activity prediction. SMURFF is available as open-source and can be used both on a supercomputer and on a deskt…
A Bayesian Boolean Matrix Factorization with Application to Copy Number Analysis in Cancer
Department of Data Science, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute(数据科学部,达纳-法伯癌症研究所);Department of Biostatistics, Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health(生物统计学部,哈佛T.H. 潘克学校公共卫生学院)
NTT DATA Mathematical Systems Inc.(NTT数据数学系统株式会社);Tokyo Institute of Technology(东京工业大学)
Latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) is useful in document analysis, image processing, and many information systems; however, its generalization performance has been left unknown because it is a singular learning machine to which regular statistical theory can not be applied. Stochastic matrix factorization (SMF) is a restricted matrix factorization in which matrix factors are stochastic; the column of the matrix is in a simplex. SMF is being applied to image recognition and text mining. We can understand SMF as a statistical model by which a stochastic matrix of given data is represented by a pr…
We derive analytical expression of matrix factorization/completion solution by variational Bayes method, under the assumption that observed matrix is originally the product of low-rank dense and sparse matrices with additive noise. We assume the prior of sparse matrix is Laplace distribution by taking matrix sparsity into consideration. Then we use several approximations for derivation of matrix factorization/completion solution. By our solution, we also numerically evaluate the performance of sparse matrix reconstruction in matrix factorization, and completion of missing matrix element in mat…
Dyadic Data Prediction (DDP) is an important problem in many research areas. This paper develops a novel fully Bayesian nonparametric framework which integrates two popular and complementary approaches, discrete mixed membership modeling and continuous latent factor modeling into a unified Heterogeneous Matrix Factorization~(HeMF) model, which can predict the unobserved dyadics accurately. The HeMF can determine the number of communities automatically and exploit the latent linear structure for each bicluster efficiently. We propose a Variational Bayesian method to estimate the parameters and …
We introduce a dynamic generative model, Bayesian allocation model (BAM), which establishes explicit connections between nonnegative tensor factorization (NTF), graphical models of discrete probability distributions and their Bayesian extensions, and the topic models such as the latent Dirichlet allocation. BAM is based on a Poisson process, whose events are marked by using a Bayesian network, where the conditional probability tables of this network are then integrated out analytically. We show that the resulting marginal process turns out to be a Polya urn, an integer valued self-reinforcing …
University of Wisconsin-Madison(威斯康星大学麦迪逊分校);Koc University(科奇大学)
We introduce a Bayesian perspective for the structured matrix factorization problem. The proposed framework provides a probabilistic interpretation for existing geometric methods based on determinant minimization. We model input data vectors as linear transformations of latent vectors drawn from a distribution uniform over a particular domain reflecting structural assumptions, such as the probability simplex in Nonnegative Matrix Factorization and polytopes in Polytopic Matrix Factorization. We represent the rows of the linear transformation matrix as vectors generated independently from a nor…
MFAI: A Scalable Bayesian Matrix Factorization Approach to Leveraging Auxiliary Information
Department of Mathematics, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology(香港科技大学数学系);Department of Biostatistics, City University of Hong Kong(香港城市大学生物统计学系)
Aalto University(阿尔托大学);School of Science and Engineering(科学与工程学院);Helsinki Institute for Information Technology(赫尔辛基信息技术研究所)
Exponential family extensions of principal component analysis (EPCA) have received a considerable amount of attention in recent years, demonstrating the growing need for basic modeling tools that do not assume the squared loss or Gaussian distribution. We extend the EPCA model toolbox by presenting the first exponential family multi-view learning methods of the partial least squares and canonical correlation analysis, based on a unified representation of EPCA as matrix factorization of the natural parameters of exponential family. The models are based on a new family of priors that are general…
Université de Lorraine(洛林大学);CNRS(法国国家科学研究中心);Inria(法国国家信息与自动化研究所);LORIA(洛林计算机科学及其应用实验室);IRIT(图卢兹信息学研究所);Université de Toulouse(图卢兹大学)
This paper tackles the problem of decomposing binary data using matrix factorization. We consider the family of mean-parametrized Bernoulli models, a class of generative models that are well suited for modeling binary data and enables interpretability of the factors. We factorize the Bernoulli parameter and consider an additional Beta prior on one of the factors to further improve the model's expressive power. While similar models have been proposed in the literature, they only exploit the Beta prior as a proxy to ensure a valid Bernoulli parameter in a Bayesian setting; in practice it reduces…
Global Blood Therapeutics(Global Blood Therapeutics(全球血液治疗公司))
The approval success rate of drug candidates is very low with the majority of failure due to safety and efficacy. Increasingly available high dimensional information on targets, drug molecules and indications provides an opportunity for ML methods to integrate multiple data modalities and better predict clinically promising drug targets. Notably, drug targets with human genetics evidence are shown to have better odds to succeed. However, a recent tensor factorization-based approach found that additional information on targets and indications might not necessarily improve the predictive accurac…
University of Science and Technology(科学技术大学);Electronics and Telecommunications Research Institute(电子通信研究院)
Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) is one of successful method in many areas such as image classification tasks. However, the amount of memory and computational cost needed for CNNs inference obstructs them to run efficiently in mobile devices because of memory and computational ability limitation. One of the method to compress CNNs is compressing the layers iteratively, i.e. by layer-by-layer compression and fine-tuning, with CP-decomposition in convolutional layers. To compress with CP-decomposition, rank selection is important. In the previous approach rank selection that is based on sens…
Helsinki Institute for Information Technology HIIT(赫尔辛基信息技术研究所);Aalto University(阿尔托大学);Institute for Molecular Medicine Finland FIMM(芬兰分子医学研究所);University of Helsinki(赫尔辛基大学);Science for Life Laboratory(生命科学实验室);Karolinska Institutet(卡罗林斯卡学院);University of Turku(图尔库大学)
A key goal of computational personalized medicine is to systematically utilize genomic and other molecular features of samples to predict drug responses for a previously unseen sample. Such predictions are valuable for developing hypotheses for selecting therapies tailored for individual patients. This is especially valuable in oncology, where molecular and genetic heterogeneity of the cells has a major impact on the response. However, the prediction task is extremely challenging, raising the need for methods that can effectively model and predict drug responses. In this study, we propose a no…
We present a scalable Bayesian model for low-rank factorization of massive tensors with binary observations. The proposed model has the following key properties: (1) in contrast to the models based on the logistic or probit likelihood, using a zero-truncated Poisson likelihood for binary data allows our model to scale up in the number of \emph{ones} in the tensor, which is especially appealing for massive but sparse binary tensors; (2) side-information in form of binary pairwise relationships (e.g., an adjacency network) between objects in any tensor mode can also be leveraged, which can be es…
In this paper a new dictionary learning algorithm for multidimensional data is proposed. Unlike most conventional dictionary learning methods which are derived for dealing with vectors or matrices, our algorithm, named KTSVD, learns a multidimensional dictionary directly via a novel algebraic approach for tensor factorization as proposed in [3, 12, 13]. Using this approach one can define a tensor-SVD and we propose to extend K-SVD algorithm used for 1-D data to a K-TSVD algorithm for handling 2-D and 3-D data. Our algorithm, based on the idea of sparse coding (using group-sparsity over multidi…
Robust Bayesian Tensor Factorization with Zero-Inflated Poisson Model and Consensus Aggregation
Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard(麻省理工学院与哈佛大学博德研究所);Klarman Cell Observatory, Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard(麻省理工学院与哈佛大学博德研究所克拉曼细胞观测站);Brigham and Women’s Hospital(布莱根妇女医院);Harvard Medical School(哈佛医学院);University of Massachusetts Boston(马萨诸塞大学波士顿分校)
We develop a Bayesian Poisson matrix factorization model for forming recommendations from sparse user behavior data. These data are large user/item matrices where each user has provided feedback on only a small subset of items, either explicitly (e.g., through star ratings) or implicitly (e.g., through views or purchases). In contrast to traditional matrix factorization approaches, Poisson factorization implicitly models each user's limited attention to consume items. Moreover, because of the mathematical form of the Poisson likelihood, the model needs only to explicitly consider the observed …
We propose a generative model for robust tensor factorization in the presence of both missing data and outliers. The objective is to explicitly infer the underlying low-CP-rank tensor capturing the global information and a sparse tensor capturing the local information (also considered as outliers), thus providing the robust predictive distribution over missing entries. The low-CP-rank tensor is modeled by multilinear interactions between multiple latent factors on which the column sparsity is enforced by a hierarchical prior, while the sparse tensor is modeled by a hierarchical view of Student…
School of Mechanical Engineering, Beijing Institute of Technology(北京理工大学机械工程学院);School of Transportation Engineering, Southeast University(东南大学交通工程学院);Faculty of Momenta(Momenta学院);McGill University(麦吉尔大学);University of Wisconsin-Madison(威斯康星大学麦迪逊分校)
Non-recurrent traffic congestion (NRTC) usually brings unexpected delays to commuters. Hence, it is critical to accurately detect and recognize the NRTC in a real-time manner. The advancement of road traffic detectors and loop detectors provides researchers with a large-scale multivariable temporal-spatial traffic data, which allows the deep research on NRTC to be conducted. However, it remains a challenging task to construct an analytical framework through which the natural spatial-temporal structural properties of multivariable traffic information can be effectively represented and exploited…
Distributed Bayesian Matrix Factorization with Limited Communication
Helsinki Institute for Information Technology HIIT, Department of Computer Science, Aalto University(赫尔辛基信息科技研究院 HIIT,计算机科学系,阿莱大学);Department of Informatics, University of Bergen(信息学院,卑尔根大学)
The preservation of our cultural heritage is of paramount importance. Thanks to recent developments in digital acquisition techniques, powerful image analysis algorithms are developed which can be useful non-invasive tools to assist in the restoration and preservation of art. In this paper we propose a semi-supervised crack detection method that can be used for high-dimensional acquisitions of paintings coming from different modalities. Our dataset consists of a recently acquired collection of images of the Ghent Altarpiece (1432), one of Northern Europe's most important art masterpieces. Our …
University of Chicago(芝加哥大学);California Institute of Technology(加州理工学院)
In this paper we derive an explicit formula for calculating the marginal likelihood of a given factorization of a categorical dataset. Since the marginal likelihood is proportional to the posterior probability of the factorization, these likelihoods can be used to order all possible factorizations and select the "best" way to factor the overall distribution from which the dataset is drawn. The best factorization can then be used to construct a Bayes classifier which benefits from factoring out mutually independent sets of variables.
UMBC(马里兰大学巴尔的摩县分校);Los Alamos National Laboratory(洛斯阿拉莫斯国家实验室)
The unprecedented outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus-2 (SARS-CoV-2), or COVID-19, continues to be a significant worldwide problem. As a result, a surge of new COVID-19 related research has followed suit. The growing number of publications requires document organization methods to identify relevant information. In this paper, we expand upon our previous work with clustering the CORD-19 dataset by applying multi-dimensional analysis methods. Tensor factorization is a powerful unsupervised learning method capable of discovering hidden patterns in a document corpus. We show …
Artificial Intelligence Technology Engineering Research Center, Open University of Henan(河南开放大学人工智能技术工程研究中心);University of Wollongong(伍伦贡大学);Weizmann Institute of Science(魏茨曼科学研究所);University of Sydney(悉尼大学)
We consider matrix factorization (MF) with certain constraints, which finds wide applications in various areas. Leveraging variational inference (VI) and unitary approximate message passing (UAMP), we develop a Bayesian approach to MF with an efficient message passing implementation, called UAMPMF. With proper priors imposed on the factor matrices, UAMPMF can be used to solve many problems that can be formulated as MF, such as non negative matrix factorization, dictionary learning, compressive sensing with matrix uncertainty, robust principal component analysis, and sparse matrix factorization…
We introduce Bayesian multi-tensor factorization, a model that is the first Bayesian formulation for joint factorization of multiple matrices and tensors. The research problem generalizes the joint matrix-tensor factorization problem to arbitrary sets of tensors of any depth, including matrices, can be interpreted as unsupervised multi-view learning from multiple data tensors, and can be generalized to relax the usual trilinear tensor factorization assumptions. The result is a factorization of the set of tensors into factors shared by any subsets of the tensors, and factors private to individu…
Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF) is a popular tool for data exploration. Bayesian NMF promises to also characterize uncertainty in the factorization. Unfortunately, current inference approaches such as MCMC mix slowly and tend to get stuck on single modes. We introduce a novel approach using rapidly-exploring random trees (RRTs) to asymptotically cover regions of high posterior density. These are placed in a principled Bayesian framework via an online extension to nonparametric variational inference. On experiments on real and synthetic data, we obtain greater coverage of the posterior …