二元论者应该(不应该)如何回应来自能量守恒的反对
How Dualists Should (Not) Respond to the Objection from Energy Conservation
摘要:
能量守恒原理被广泛认为是相互作用二元论(无论是性质还是物质)的一个严重困难。因此,互动主义者经常试图使它满足能量守恒。本文分析了几个这样的尝试,特别是包括E。J. Lowe的可变常数提议,显示了它们是如何由于缺乏与能量守恒物理学的物理数学根源的接触而错过目标的:第一诺特定理(对称性意味着守恒定律),它的逆定理(守恒定律意味着对称性),以及连续统/场物理学的局部性。因此,“条件性反应”,它认为守恒是(双)对称性的条件,并简单地接受能量不守恒作为相互作用二元论的一个方面,被认为是,也许令人惊讶的是,最符合当代物理学(除了量子力学),不与物理学基本的数学定理相冲突。对互动论的一个体面的反对应该是后验的,基于对大脑的经验研究。
英文摘要:
The principle of energy conservation is widely taken to be a serious difficulty for interactionist dualism (whether property or substance). Interactionists often have therefore tried to make it satisfy energy conservation. This paper examines several such attempts, especially including E. J. Lowe's varying constants proposal, showing how they all miss their goal due to lack of engagement with the physico-mathematical roots of energy conservation physics: the first Noether theorem (that symmetries imply conservation laws), its converse (that conservation laws imply symmetries), and the locality of continuum/field physics. Thus the "conditionality response", which sees conservation as (bi)conditional upon symmetries and simply accepts energy non-conservation as an aspect of interactionist dualism, is seen to be, perhaps surprisingly, the one most in accord with contemporary physics (apart from quantum mechanics) by not conflicting with mathematical theorems basic to physics. A decent objection to interactionism should be a posteriori, based on empirically studying the brain.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。