薛定谔和普朗克振荡器:不完全相同的物理学
Schrödinger and Planck oscillators: not quite the same physics
摘要:
在量子谐振子的统计力学中,零点能量可以被包含(薛定谔振荡器)或省略(普朗克振荡器)。对于通常的结果,振荡器的类型没有区别,但是,更仔细地看,结果表明,包括或不包括这种能量并非没有后果。薛定谔振子组的化学势μs用正则形式计算,这表明存在一个温度T0,μs=0;低于这个温度,μs>0。当使用普朗克振子时,化学势μp对所有温度都是负的。如果这个问题是在声子方面和系统被认为是在接触的粒子库(条件的巨正则系综),一种临界温度Tc的发现,在该系统中的粒子数发散。对于μs=0的薛定谔振子,我们发现Tc=T0,即T0在正则系综中提醒我们,在巨正则系综的条件下,粒子数的发散行为。此外,一个修改的爱因斯坦固体(MES)模型。在这个模型中,振子的频率随着固体体积的变化而变化,这种变化由一定的Grüneisen参数值来表征。这种固体的体积弹性模量可以用普朗克振荡器计算,对于某些温度和体积值,它会变成负值,这在物理上是不正确的。当使用薛定谔振荡器时,体积模量总是正值。因此,两种类型的振荡器的不同行为表明,只有薛定谔振荡器导致正确的结果。
英文摘要:
In the statistical mechanics of quantum harmonic oscillators, the zero-point energy can either be included (Schrödinger oscillators) or omitted (Planck oscillators). For the usual results, the type of oscillator makes no difference but, looking more closely, it turns out that including or not this energy is not without consequences. The chemical potential μs of a Schrödinger oscillator set is calculated in the canonical formalism and this shows there is a temperature T0 for which μs=0; below this temperature, μs>0. When Planck oscillators are used instead, the chemical potential μp is negative for all temperatures. If the problem is approached in phonon terms and the system is considered to be in contact with a reservoir of particles (conditions of the grand canonical ensemble), a sort of critical temperature Tc is found, for which the number of particles in the system diverges. For Schrödinger oscillators with μs=0, it turns out that Tc=T0, i.e. T0 is a reminder, in the canonical ensemble, of the divergent behavior in the number of particles when under the conditions of the grand canonical ensemble. Also, a modified Einstein solid (MES) model is introduced. In this model the frequency of the oscillators changes with the volume of the solid, and this change is characterized by a certain value of the Grüneisen parameter. The bulk modulus of this solid can be calculated using Planck oscillators, and it becomes negative for certain temperature and volume values, which is physically incorrect. When Schrödinger oscillators are used, the bulk modulus is always positive. Therefore, the different behavior of both types of oscillators would indicate that only Schrödinger oscillators lead to correct results.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。