arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1908.08893cs.HCcs.GR
收藏

您无法发布复制研究(以及如何发布)

You Can't Publish Replication Studies (and How to Anyways)

Ghulam Jilani Quadri, Paul Rosen

摘要:

科学界越来越多地鼓励复制,以验证实验结论,复制研究代表了视觉科学家希望为可视化社区贡献新的感知模型,方法或见解的重要机会。不幸的是,复制先前研究的概念并不适合我们如何交流研究结果。简单地说,重新进行和确认早期结果的研究并不具有任何新颖性,这是现代研究出版体系的关键要素。尽管如此,精明的研究人员已经发现了通过将复制研究嵌入到其他足够新颖的研究中来进行复制研究的方法。在这份立场文件中,我们定义了三种方法-重新评估,扩展和专业化-将复制研究嵌入到一个新的出版作品中。在这种情况下,我们提供了一个非详尽的案例研究复制克利夫兰和麦吉尔的开创性工作的图形感知。事实证明,在这项工作的基础上进行了大量的复制研究,这些研究既证实了先前的发现,又为我们对人类感知的理解提供了新的视角。最后,我们讨论了如何出版一个真正的复制研究应避免,同时提供建议,视觉科学家和其他人如何仍然可以使用复制研究作为一种工具,以生产可视化研究出版物。

英文摘要:

Reproducibility has been increasingly encouraged by communities of science in order to validate experimental conclusions, and replication studies represent a significant opportunity to vision scientists wishing contribute new perceptual models, methods, or insights to the visualization community. Unfortunately, the notion of replication of previous studies does not lend itself to how we communicate research findings. Simple put, studies that re-conduct and confirm earlier results do not hold any novelty, a key element to the modern research publication system. Nevertheless, savvy researchers have discovered ways to produce replication studies by embedding them into other sufficiently novel studies. In this position paper, we define three methods -- re-evaluation, expansion, and specialization -- for embedding a replication study into a novel published work. Within this context, we provide a non-exhaustive case study on replications of Cleveland and McGill's seminal work on graphical perception. As it turns out, numerous replication studies have been carried out based on that work, which have both confirmed prior findings and shined new light on our understanding of human perception. Finally, we discuss how publishing a true replication study should be avoided, while providing suggestions for how vision scientists and others can still use replication studies as a vehicle to producing visualization research publications.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑