arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1908.01408stat.AP
收藏

对现代艺术的防御:统计学的诅咒

Defence Against the Modern Arts: the Curse of Statistics -- FRStat

Cedric Neumann

摘要:

几十年来,法律和科学学者一直认为,法医检查的结论应该得到统计数据的支持,并在概率框架内报告。已经提出了多种模型来量化法医证据的证明价值。不幸的是,其中一些模型依赖于不科学的临时策略。用于介绍这些模型及其结果的技术术语的不透明性以及所涉及的技术的复杂性使得未经训练的用户很难将小麦与谷壳分开。这一系列的文件旨在帮助法医科学家和律师认识到提出的解释法医检查结果的工具中的问题。本文重点介绍了由美国国防法医科学中心(DFSC)的潜在打印分支机构提出的称为FRStat的工具。在本文中,我探讨了FRStat输出的结果与DFCS用来报告其指纹检查结论的语言的兼容性,以及支撑该工具的统计建模的适当性及其性能的验证。

英文摘要:

For several decades, legal and scientific scholars have argued that conclusions from forensic examinations should be supported by statistical data and reported within a probabilistic framework. Multiple models have been proposed to quantify the probative value of forensic evidence. Unfortunately, several of these models rely on ad-hoc strategies that are not scientifically sound. The opacity of the technical jargon that is used to present these models and their results and the complexity of the techniques involved make it very difficult for the untrained user to separate the wheat from the chaff. This series of paper is intended to help forensic scientists and lawyers recognise issues in tools proposed to interpret the results of forensic examinations. This paper focuses on the tool proposed by the Latent Print Branch of the U.S. Defense Forensic Science Center (DFSC) and called FRStat. In this paper, I explore the compatibility of the results outputted by FRStat with the language used by the DFCS to report the conclusions of their fingerprint examinations, as well as the appropriateness of the statistical modelling underpinning the tool and the validation of its performance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑