截断Y轴:威胁还是威胁?
Truncating the Y-Axis: Threat or Menace?
摘要:
Y轴不从零开始的条形图可能会在视觉上夸大效果大小。但是,对于其他可视化类型,是否截断y轴的建议可能不明确。在本文中,我们提出了可视化的例子,其中Y轴截断可以是有益的,也可以是有害的,这取决于沟通和分析的意图。我们还提出了一系列众包实验的结果,在这些实验中,我们研究了y轴截断如何影响可视化类型的主观效应大小,并探索了更直接地提醒观众注意这种截断的替代设计。我们发现,轴截断的主观影响是持久的可视化设计,即使是明确的视觉线索,表明截断已经发生的设计。我们建议设计师考虑他们打算传达的有意义的效果大小和变化的规模,无论视觉编码如何。
英文摘要:
Bar charts with y-axes that don't begin at zero can visually exaggerate effect sizes. However, advice for whether or not to truncate the y-axis can be equivocal for other visualization types. In this paper we present examples of visualizations where this y-axis truncation can be beneficial as well as harmful, depending on the communicative and analytic intent. We also present the results of a series of crowd-sourced experiments in which we examine how y-axis truncation impacts subjective effect size across visualization types, and we explore alternative designs that more directly alert viewers to this truncation. We find that the subjective impact of axis truncation is persistent across visualizations designs, even for designs with explicit visual cues that indicate truncation has taken place. We suggest that designers consider the scale of the meaningful effect sizes and variation they intend to communicate, regardless of the visual encoding.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。