arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1906.06505cs.CR
收藏

是不是“www.“意味着更好的传输层安全性?

Does "www." Mean Better Transport Layer Security?

Eman Salem Alashwali, Pawel Szalachowski, Andrew Martin

摘要:

经验表明,大多数研究人员和开发人员倾向于将普通域名(那些没有前缀为“www”的子域,例如“example.com“)视为其等效www域名(那些前缀为“www”的子域,例如“www.example.com“)的同义词。在本文中,我们分析了近200万个普通域的数据集,并与其等效的www域进行了比较,以回答以下问题:普通域和其等效的www域在TLS安全配置和证书方面是否存在差异?如果是,程度如何?我们的研究结果提供了一个有趣的现象的证据:普通域和它们的等价www域在TLS安全配置和证书方面存在差异。此外,www域名往往比其等效的普通域名具有更强的安全配置。有趣的是,这种现象在访问量最大的域中比在随机选择的域中更普遍。对顶级域数据集的进一步分析表明,53.35%的普通域显示了一个或多个在其等效www域中未显示的弱点指标(例如过期证书),这些普通域执行从HTTPS普通域到其等效HTTPS www域的HTTPS重定向。此外,这些重定向中有24.71%包含纯文本HTTP中间URL。在这些情况下,用户看到的是具有强TLS配置和证书的最终www域,但实际上,HTTPS请求已经通过了具有较不安全的TLS配置和证书的普通域。显然,这样的设置在整个交互的安全性中引入了一个薄弱环节。

英文摘要:

Experience shows that most researchers and developers tend to treat plain-domains (those that are not prefixed with "www" sub-domains, e.g. "example.com") as synonyms for their equivalent www-domains (those that are prefixed with "www" sub-domains, e.g. "www.example.com"). In this paper, we analyse datasets of nearly two million plain-domains against their equivalent www-domains to answer the following question: Do plain-domains and their equivalent www-domains differ in TLS security configurations and certificates? If so, to what extent? Our results provide evidence of an interesting phenomenon: plain-domains and their equivalent www-domains differ in TLS security configurations and certificates in a non-trivial number of cases. Furthermore, www-domains tend to have stronger security configurations than their equivalent plain-domains. Interestingly, this phenomenon is more prevalent in the most-visited domains than in randomly-chosen domains. Further analysis of the top domains dataset shows that 53.35% of the plain-domains that show one or more weakness indicators (e.g. expired certificate) that are not shown in their equivalent www-domains perform HTTPS redirection from HTTPS plain-domains to their equivalent HTTPS www-domains. Additionally, 24.71% of these redirections contains plain-text HTTP intermediate URLs. In these cases, users see the final www-domains with strong TLS configurations and certificates, but in fact, the HTTPS request has passed through plain-domains that have less secure TLS configurations and certificates. Clearly, such a set-up introduces a weak link in the security of the overall interaction.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑