This paper surveys an approach to the XAI problem, using post-hoc explanation by example, that hinges on twinning Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs) with Case-Based Reasoning (CBR) systems, so-called ANN-CBR twins. A systematic survey of 1100+ papers was carried out to identify the fragmented literature on this topic and to trace it influence through to more recent work involving Deep Neural Networks (DNNs). The paper argues that this twin-system approach, especially using ANN-CBR twins, presents one possible coherent, generic solution to the XAI problem (and, indeed, XCBR problem). The paper concludes by road-mapping some future directions for this XAI solution involving (i) further tests of feature-weighting techniques, (iii) explorations of how explanatory cases might best be deployed (e.g., in counterfactuals, near-miss cases, a fortori cases), and (iii) the raising of the unwelcome and, much ignored, issue of human user evaluation.
University College Dublin（都柏林大学学院）；Insight Centre for Data Analytics（洞察数据分析中心）；VistaMilk SFI Research Centre（VistaMilk SFI研究中心）
The notion of twin systems is proposed to address the eXplainable AI (XAI) problem, where an uninterpretable black-box system is mapped to a white-box 'twin' that is more interpretable. In this short paper, we overview very recent work that advances a generic solution to the XAI problem, the so called twin system approach. The most popular twinning in the literature is that between an Artificial Neural Networks (ANN ) as a black box and Case Based Reasoning (CBR) system as a white-box, where the latter acts as an interpretable proxy for the former. We outline how recent work reviving this idea…
The underlying hypothesis of knowledge-based explainable artificial intelligence is the data required for data-centric artificial intelligence agents (e.g., neural networks) are less diverse in contents than the data required to explain the decisions of such agents to humans. The idea is that a classifier can attain high accuracy using data that express a phenomenon from one perspective whereas the audience of explanations can entail multiple stakeholders and span diverse perspectives. We hence propose to use domain knowledge to complement the data used by agents. We formulate knowledge-based …
Previous research in interpretable machine learning (IML) and explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) can be broadly categorized as either focusing on seeking interpretability in the agent's model (i.e., IML) or focusing on the context of the user in addition to the model (i.e., XAI). The former can be categorized as feature or instance attribution. Example- or sample-based methods such as those using or inspired by case-based reasoning (CBR) rely on various approaches to select instances that are not necessarily attributing instances responsible for an agent's decision. Furthermore, existin…
University College Dublin（都柏林大学学院）；Teagasc（爱尔兰农业与食品发展局）
Climate change poses a major challenge to humanity, especially in its impact on agriculture, a challenge that a responsible AI should meet. In this paper, we examine a CBR system (PBI-CBR) designed to aid sustainable dairy farming by supporting grassland management, through accurate crop growth prediction. As climate changes, PBI-CBRs historical cases become less useful in predicting future grass growth. Hence, we extend PBI-CBR using data augmentation, to specifically handle disruptive climate events, using a counterfactual method (from XAI). Study 1 shows that historical, extreme climate-eve…
Berlin University of Applied Sciences（柏林应用科学大学）；Einstein Center Digital Future（爱因斯坦数字未来中心）
Insects are a crucial part of our ecosystem. Sadly, in the past few decades, their numbers have worryingly decreased. In an attempt to gain a better understanding of this process and monitor the insects populations, Deep Learning may offer viable solutions. However, given the breadth of their taxonomy and the typical hurdles of fine grained analysis, such as high intraclass variability compared to low interclass variability, insect classification remains a challenging task. There are few benchmark datasets, which impedes rapid development of better AI models. The annotation of rare species tra…
Finding the right XAI method -- A Guide for the Evaluation and Ranking of Explainable AI Methods in Climate Science
Technische Universität Berlin（柏林工业大学）；ATB（莱布尼茨农业工程与生物经济研究所）；University of Leipzig（莱比锡大学）；University of Reading（雷丁大学）；BIFOLD – Berlin Institute for the Foundations of Learning and Data（柏林学习与数据基础研究所（BIFOLD））；UiT the Arctic University of Norway（挪威北极大学）；University of Potsdam（波茨坦大学）
University College Dublin（都柏林大学）；Insight Centre for Data Analytics（洞察数据分析中心）；VistaMilk SFI Research Centre（VistaMilk SFI研究中心）
Recently, it has been proposed that fruitful synergies may exist between Deep Learning (DL) and Case Based Reasoning (CBR); that there are insights to be gained by applying CBR ideas to problems in DL (what could be called DeepCBR). In this paper, we report on a program of research that applies CBR solutions to the problem of Explainable AI (XAI) in the DL. We describe a series of twin-systems pairings of opaque DL models with transparent CBR models that allow the latter to explain the former using factual, counterfactual and semi-factual explanation strategies. This twinning shows that functi…
Confident Teacher, Confident Student? A Novel User Study Design for Investigating the Didactic Potential of Explanations and their Impact on Uncertainty
Berliner Hochschule für Technik（柏林应用科学大学）；Einstein Center Digital Future（爱因斯坦数字未来中心）
In this document I present an approach to answer validation and reranking for question answering (QA) systems. A cased-based reasoning (CBR) system judges answer candidates for questions from annotated answer candidates for earlier questions. The promise of this approach is that user feedback will result in improved answers of the QA system, due to the growing case base. In the paper, I present the adequate structuring of the case base and the appropriate selection of relevant similarity measures, in order to solve the answer validation problem. The structural case base is built from annotated…
The Meta-Evaluation Problem in Explainable AI: Identifying Reliable Estimators with MetaQuantus
Technical University of Berlin（柏林工业大学）；Berlin Institute for the Foundations of Learning and Data（柏林学习与数据基础研究所）；UiT Arctic University of Norway（挪威北极大学）；Fraunhofer Heinrich-Hertz-Institute（弗劳恩霍夫海因里希·赫兹研究所）；University of Potsdam（波茨坦大学）；Leibniz Institute of Agricultural Engineering and Bioeconomy e.V.（莱布尼茨农业工程与生物经济研究所）
Beuth University of Applied Sciences（博伊特应用科学大学）；Einstein Center Digital Future（爱因斯坦数字未来中心）
The field explainable artificial intelligence (XAI) has brought about an arsenal of methods to render Machine Learning (ML) predictions more interpretable. But how useful explanations provided by transparent ML methods are for humans remains difficult to assess. Here we investigate the quality of interpretable computer vision algorithms using techniques from psychophysics. In crowdsourced annotation tasks we study the impact of different interpretability approaches on annotation accuracy and task time. We compare these quality metrics with classical XAI, automated quality metrics. Our results …
Exploring Energy Landscapes for Minimal Counterfactual Explanations: Applications in Cybersecurity and Beyond
Netcompany-Intrasoft S.A.（Netcompany-Intrasoft公司）；Hellenic Mediterranean University（希腊地中海大学）；Harokopio University of Athens（雅典哈罗科皮奥大学）；University of Western Macedonia（西马其顿大学）
EXGnet: a single-lead explainable-AI guided multiresolution network with train-only quantitative features for trustworthy ECG arrhythmia classification
Dept. of Electrical and Electronic Engineering（电子与电气工程系）；Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology（孟加拉工程与技术大学）；Dept. of Electronics & Communication Engineering（电子与通信工程系）；Khulna University of Engineering and Technology（库尔纳工程与技术大学）
University of South Carolina（南卡罗来纳大学）；Artificial Intelligence Institute（人工智能研究所）
Improving the performance and natural language explanations of deep learning algorithms is a priority for adoption by humans in the real world. In several domains, such as healthcare, such technology has significant potential to reduce the burden on humans by providing quality assistance at scale. However, current methods rely on the traditional pipeline of predicting labels from data, thus completely ignoring the process and guidelines used to obtain the labels. Furthermore, post hoc explanations on the data to label prediction using explainable AI (XAI) models, while satisfactory to computer…
Stony Brook University（石溪大学）；IBM Research AI（IBM研究院人工智能部门）
The wide adoption of Machine Learning technologies has created a rapidly growing demand for people who can train ML models. Some advocated the term "machine teacher" to refer to the role of people who inject domain knowledge into ML models. One promising learning paradigm is Active Learning (AL), by which the model intelligently selects instances to query the machine teacher for labels. However, in current AL settings, the human-AI interface remains minimal and opaque. We begin considering AI explanations as a core element of the human-AI interface for teaching machines. When a human student l…
Institute for Research in Technology (IIT)（技术研究机构）；ICAI School of Engineering（工程学院）；Universidad Pontificia Comillas（Pontificia Comillas大学）；Department of Applied Mathematics（应用数学系）；Department of Quantitative Methods（定量方法系）；ICADE（ICADE学院）
University of Trier（特里尔大学）；German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI)（德国人工智能研究中心（DFKI））
Currently, Deep Learning (DL) components within a Case-Based Reasoning (CBR) application often lack the comprehensive integration of available domain knowledge. The trend within machine learning towards so-called Informed machine learning can help to overcome this limitation. In this paper, we therefore investigate the potential of integrating domain knowledge into Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) that are used for similarity assessment between semantic graphs within process-oriented CBR applications. We integrate knowledge in two ways: First, a special data representation and processing method is…
University of Tübingen（图宾根大学）；MPI for Informatics（马克斯·普朗克信息学研究所）；MPI for Intelligent Systems（马克斯·普朗克智能系统研究所）
Explaining the decision of a multi-modal decision-maker requires to determine the evidence from both modalities. Recent advances in XAI provide explanations for models trained on still images. However, when it comes to modeling multiple sensory modalities in a dynamic world, it remains underexplored how to demystify the mysterious dynamics of a complex multi-modal model. In this work, we take a crucial step forward and explore learnable explanations for audio-visual recognition. Specifically, we propose a novel space-time attention network that uncovers the synergistic dynamics of audio and vi…
