arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1903.01149physics.soc-phcs.DLcs.SI
收藏

感知、声望与PageRank

Perception, Prestige and PageRank

David Zeitlyn, Daniel W Hook

摘要:

学术上的尊重很难用客观的术语来量化。网络理论提供了使用数学形式主义来建模与学者相关的尊重以及学术同事之间的关系的机会。早期的尝试使用这种推理方式,主要集中在由导师学生网络构成的智力谱系上。考试过程在许多研究领域都很重要,但在现有模式中没有发挥作用。一个网络理论的“社会”模型,提出了作为一种工具,探索和理解的动态尊重的学术等级。据观察,这样的模型自然会产生这样的想法,即与图中的节点相关联的尊重(个人学术的尊重)可以被视为一个动态量,该动态量基于网络中属性的局部和非局部变化而随时间演变。本文所研究的玩具模型包括导师-学生关系和考官-学生关系。这让我们深入了解了学术系谱的一些关键特征,并自然地导致了学术网络上的“尊重传播”模型。这种传播不仅在时间上是向前的(从老师到后代),有时也会向另一个方向流动。当合作者做得很好时,这很好地反映了他们选择与之合作的人和教他们的人。此外,即使在一段关系或职业生涯结束后,尊重作为一个数量仍然是动态的。换句话说,尊重可以被认为是在时间上向前和向后流动的。

英文摘要:

Academic esteem is difficult to quantify in objective terms. Network theory offers the opportunity to use a mathematical formalism to model both the esteem associated with an academic and the relationships between academic colleagues. Early attempts using this line of reasoning have focused on intellectual genealogy as constituted by supervisor student networks. The process of examination is critical in many areas of study but has not played a part in existing models. A network theoretical "social" model is proposed as a tool to explore and understand the dynamics of esteem in the academic hierarchy. It is observed that such a model naturally gives rise to the idea that the esteem associated with a node in the graph (the esteem of an individual academic) can be viewed as a dynamic quantity that evolves with time based on both local and non-local changes in the properties in the network. The toy model studied here includes both supervisor-student and examiner-student relationships. This gives an insight into some of the key features of academic genealogies and naturally leads to a proposed model for "esteem propagation" on academic networks. This propagation is not solely directed forward in time (from teacher to progeny) but sometimes also flows in the other direction. As collaborators do well, this reflects well on those with whom they choose to collaborate and those that taught them. Furthermore, esteem as a quantity continues to be dynamic even after the end of a relationship or career. In other words, esteem can be thought of as flowing both forward and backward in time.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑