评“解决费米悖论的夏眠假说”
Comment on 'The aestivation hypothesis for resolving Fermi's paradox'
摘要:
在他们的文章[arXiv:1705.03394]中,“那不是死的,它可以永恒的谎言:解决费米悖论的夏眠假说”,桑德伯格等人试图解释费米悖论(我们看不到外星人),声称兰道尔原理意味着文明原则上可以执行更多(${\sim} 10^{30}$倍)不可逆的逻辑运算(例如,纠错位擦除),如果它保存其资源,直到遥远的未来,当宇宙背景温度非常低。所以也许外星人就在那里,只是静静地等待着。然而,桑德伯格等人隐含地假设,计算机产生的熵只能通过将其转移到宇宙学背景中来处理。事实上,虽然这个假设可能在遥远的未来适用,但我们今天的宇宙包含了巨大的水库和其他处于非最大熵状态的物理系统,计算机生成的熵可以以一位负熵的绝热转换率转移到它们身上,以消除一位错误。这可以在任何时候完成,并且不会通过等待低宇宙背景温度来改善。因此,外星人不需要等待才能活跃起来。由于桑德伯格等人没有提供一个具体的模型来证明他们所主张的效果,我们构建了一个模型,并指出他们的非正式论点错在哪里。
英文摘要:
In their article [arXiv:1705.03394], 'That is not dead which can eternal lie: the aestivation hypothesis for resolving Fermi's paradox', Sandberg et al. try to explain the Fermi paradox (we see no aliens) by claiming that Landauer's principle implies that a civilization can in principle perform far more (${\sim} 10^{30}$ times more) irreversible logical operations (e.g., error-correcting bit erasures) if it conserves its resources until the distant future when the cosmic background temperature is very low. So perhaps aliens are out there, but quietly waiting. Sandberg et al. implicitly assume, however, that computer-generated entropy can only be disposed of by transferring it to the cosmological background. In fact, while this assumption may apply in the distant future, our universe today contains vast reservoirs and other physical systems in non-maximal entropy states, and computer-generated entropy can be transferred to them at the adiabatic conversion rate of one bit of negentropy to erase one bit of error. This can be done at any time, and is not improved by waiting for a low cosmic background temperature. Thus aliens need not wait to be active. As Sandberg et al. do not provide a concrete model of the effect they assert, we construct one and show where their informal argument goes wrong.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。