arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1902.04940econ.GNphysics.soc-phq-fin.EC
收藏

公平报酬问题:成功的幻觉以及如何解决它

The fair reward problem: the illusion of success and how to solve it

Didier Sornette, Spencer Wheatley, Peter Cauwels

摘要:

自古以来,人类一直着迷于追求财富,许多成功的结果都得益于运气。但成功受制于复杂性、不确定性和变化--而且有时会变得越来越不平等。这导致了人们在多大程度上得到了他们应得的东西(即,公平/精英管理)。此外,在许多领域,人类过于自信,普遍将运气与技能混为一谈(我赢了,是技能;我输了,是运气不好)。在某些领域,风险太大;在其他领域,风险还不够。如果成功在很大程度上来自运气--尤其是在救助扭曲激励措施的情况下(正面,我赢了;反面,你输了)--那么运气的回报就太多了。这刺激了赌博文化,同时淡化了生产性努力的重要性。而且,短期的成功往往是奖励,无论如何,并可能在损害,长期系统的适应性。然而,许多成功都是真正的精英管理,问题是要根据优点进行识别和奖励。我们称之为公平报酬问题。为了解决这个问题,我们提出了三种不同的措施来评估优点:(i)原始结果;(ii)风险调整后的结果;(iii)前瞻性。我们强调,在许多情况下,演绎的前瞻性的方法,它认为系统的潜力,以适应和突变的新的未来。这是在一个演变系统内正式确定的,该系统由五个进程组成,除其他外,处理勘探-开采权衡问题。通过这些镜头分析了包括金融、政治和科学在内的几项人类努力,并提出了支持繁荣和精英社会的具体解决方案。

英文摘要:

Humanity has been fascinated by the pursuit of fortune since time immemorial, and many successful outcomes benefit from strokes of luck. But success is subject to complexity, uncertainty, and change - and at times becoming increasingly unequally distributed. This leads to tension and confusion over to what extent people actually get what they deserve (i.e., fairness/meritocracy). Moreover, in many fields, humans are over-confident and pervasively confuse luck for skill (I win, it's skill; I lose, it's bad luck). In some fields, there is too much risk taking; in others, not enough. Where success derives in large part from luck - and especially where bailouts skew the incentives (heads, I win; tails, you lose) - it follows that luck is rewarded too much. This incentivizes a culture of gambling, while downplaying the importance of productive effort. And, short term success is often rewarded, irrespective, and potentially at the detriment, of the long-term system fitness. However, much success is truly meritocratic, and the problem is to discern and reward based on merit. We call this the fair reward problem. To address this, we propose three different measures to assess merit: (i) raw outcome; (ii) risk adjusted outcome, and (iii) prospective. We emphasize the need, in many cases, for the deductive prospective approach, which considers the potential of a system to adapt and mutate in novel futures. This is formalized within an evolutionary system, comprised of five processes, inter alia handling the exploration-exploitation trade-off. Several human endeavors - including finance, politics, and science -are analyzed through these lenses, and concrete solutions are proposed to support a prosperous and meritocratic society.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑