arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1902.03905astro-ph.HEphysics.hist-ph
收藏

GW170817之前的多信使研究

Multimessenger Research before GW170817

Giuseppina Modestino

摘要:

本文结合近几十年来的研究成果,结合伽马射线暴与引力波关联的实验研究经验,对GW170817和GRB170817 A的联合观测及其发现的创新性进行客观评价。在不讨论天体物理事件的现象学性质的情况下,我建议将该结果与干涉仪GW社区以前的实验研究进行比较,使用基本的能量发射定律,并包括大约15年的一致检测的认可结果。从目前的审查,一个激烈的和旧的预先存在的活动在多信使观测领域出现了第一个有趣的事实。人们普遍认为,联合探测GW170817和GRB170817A为天体物理学开辟了一种新的方法,但这并没有找到一个强有力的理由。此外,一些关键点突出。在过去,应用相同的多信使方法,已经对更亮和更近的源采取了许多措施。那么,即使考虑到当时仪器的灵敏度较差,也可能看到联合信号。目前,只有一个事件与阈下GRB相关,相比之下,一长串候选事件会更有启发性。如果这些不一致性是允许的,足以导致索赔,那么问题就出现了关于解释长期以来的测量进行了应用相同的多信使观测方法,但没有积极的反应。

英文摘要:

Linking the previous research that occurred over the last decades, I will try to provide some objective elements to evaluate the innovation of the joint observation of GW170817 and GRB 170817A and their occurrence detection, in light of preceding experiences regarding the experimental research of association between gamma-ray bursts and gravitational waves. Without debating about the phenomenological properties of astrophysical events, I propose a comparison between that result and the previous experimental research by the interferometer GW community, using a fundamental energy emission law, and including about fifteen years of accredited results regarding coincident detection. From the present review, an intense and old pre-existing activity in the field of multimessenger observations emerges giving a first interesting fact. The widespread opinion that joint detection of GW170817 and GRB 170817A has opened a new method in astrophysics does not find a robust reason. Moreover, some critical points highlight. In the past, applying the same multimessenger method, numerous measures have been taken towards much brighter and much closer sources. Then, it would have been plausible to see joint signals even taking into account a worse sensitivity of the instruments of the time. At current time, there is only one event associated to a subthreshold GRB, compared to a long list of candidate events that would have been much more revealing. If these inconsistencies are admissible enough to lead to a claim, then the question arises about the interpretation of the long previous measurements carried out applying the same multimessenger observation method but without positive responses.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑