人类运动感知的抑制和促进:对Sundermo & Murray(2018)的回复
Suppression and facilitation of motion perception in humans: a reply to Schallmo & Murray (2018)
摘要:
在最近的出版物(Tzvetanov(2018),bioRxiv 465807)中,我对D.Tadin博士的简单实验设计(Tadin,Lappin,Gilroy和Blake(2003),Nature,424:312-315)进行了广泛的分析,该实验设计是关于刺激的大小和对比度引起的人类运动感知变化。该出版物源于Sagrammo等人(2018)(eLife,7:e30334)关于两个重要观点的强烈主张:(1)“分裂正常化”,而不是抑制和兴奋机制,产生了观察到的心理物理结果;(2)药物增强抑制显示出暗示“较弱抑制”(即抑制)而不是更强“抑制”的感知结果。Sagrammo & Murray(2018,bioRxiv,495291)对我的大量出版物表示担忧,特别是我直接分析他们的一些方法,结果和主张的部分。在这里,我表明,他们的关注并没有提供明确的答案,我的具体点,并进一步没有提到其他主要的数据解释和建模的实验设计的批评。因此,我坚持我在第一篇出版物(Tzvetanov,2018,bioRxiv 465807)中详细阐述的所有主张:分析他们和其他研究结果的具体主张,以及适用于使用D. Tadin博士简单实验设计的任何研究的更广泛的建模。
英文摘要:
In a recent publication (Tzvetanov (2018), bioRxiv 465807), I made an extensive analysis with computational modelling and psychophysics of the simple experimental design of Dr. D.Tadin (Tadin, Lappin, Gilroy and Blake (2003), Nature, 424:312-315) about motion perception changes in humans due to size and contrast of the stimulus. This publication sparked from strong claims made in Schallmo et al. (2018) (eLife, 7:e30334) about two important points: (1) "divisive normalization", not inhibitory and excitatory mechanisms, creates the observed psychophysical results and (2) drug-enhanced inhibition showed perceptual outcomes that hint to "weaker suppression" (i.e. inhibition) not stronger "suppression". Schallmo & Murray (2018, bioRxiv, 495291) presented concerns about my extensive publication, specifically about the parts where I directly analysed some of their methods, results and claims. Here, I show that their concerns do not provide clear answers to my specific points and further do not mention other major critiques of data interpretation and modelling of this experimental design. Therefore, I maintain all my claims that were elaborated in details in my first publication (Tzvetanov, 2018, bioRxiv 465807): the specific ones that analyse the results of their and other studies, but also the more broad modelling that is applicable to any study using the simple experimental design of Dr. D.Tadin.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。