arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1812.04478cs.HCcs.CY
收藏

Socratrees:探索面向外行用户的论证技术设计

Socratrees: Exploring the Design of Argument Technology for Layman Users

Steven Jeuris

摘要:

“错误信息”、“假新闻”和“回声室”等术语充斥着当前关于互联网状况的讨论。我们认为,这些问题的根源在于缺乏技术支持,无法对在线信息进行评估、竞争和推理,而不仅仅是传播信息。一些参数技术支持这种功能,但在利基社区之外的使用有限。大多数研究系统过分强调论证分析和结构,与日常论证的非正式辩证性质形成鲜明对比。相反,非学术系统忽视了可以从理论中得出的设计的重要意义。在本文中,我们提出了一个系统的设计,旨在结构化论证和易用性之间取得平衡。Socratrees是一个针对外行用户的协作性辩论讨论网站,但包括复杂的社区指南和受非正式逻辑启发的新颖功能。在一项探索性研究中,我们评估了我们强加的结构对论证的有用性,并调查了用户如何看待它。为论证做出贡献仍然是一项复杂的任务,但大多数用户学会了在最小的指导下有效地这样做,并且都认识到Socratrees的结构可能会改善在线讨论,并导致更清晰的论证概述。

英文摘要:

Terms like 'misinformation', 'fake news', and 'echo chambers' permeate current discussions on the state of the Internet. We believe a lack of technological support to evaluate, contest, and reason about information online---as opposed to merely disseminating it---lies at the root of these problems. Several argument technologies support such functionality, but have seen limited use outside of niche communities. Most research systems overemphasize argument analysis and structure, standing in stark contrast with the informal dialectical nature of everyday argumentation. Conversely, non-academic systems overlook important implications for design which can be derived from theory. In this paper, we present the design of a system aiming to strike a balance between structured argumentation and ease of use. Socratrees is a website for collaborative argumentative discussion targeting layman users, but includes sophisticated community guidelines and novel features inspired by informal logic. During an exploratory study, we evaluate the usefulness of our imposed structure on argumentation and investigate how users perceive it. Contributing to arguments remains a complex task, but most users learned to do so effectively with minimal guidance and all recognized that the structure of Socratrees may improve online discussion and results in a clearer overview of arguments.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑