arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1811.09240stat.AP
收藏

我们是否应该在学校增值模型中调整学生背景?英国进步8与学校问责制研究

Should we adjust for pupil background in school value-added models? A study of Progress 8 and school accountability in England

George Leckie, Harvey Goldstein

摘要:

在英国、美国和其他地方,学校问责制度越来越多地使用从学生在高风险标准化考试中的分数得出的学校表现增值指标来比较学校。这些衡量标准不是天真地比较学校的平均成绩,因为平均成绩在很大程度上反映了学校入学人数在以前成绩方面的差异,而是试图比较学生在一年或一个阶段的学校教育中取得的平均进步或进步。然而,学校在学生的人口统计和社会经济特征方面也存在差异,这些特征也可以预测为什么一些学校后来的得分高于其他学校。因此,许多人认为,未经调整学生背景的增值措施偏向于招收更多“教育方面”的学校。但是,其他人担心,根据学生背景进行调整会加深社会经济不平等,并为表现不佳的学校找借口。在这篇文章中,我们探讨这些理论的论点和他们的实际意义的背景下,在英国的“进步8”中学问责制度,选择忽略学生的背景。我们揭示了许多学校的低或高的性能变化显着,一旦调整学生的背景,这些变化也会影响报告的区域和不同学校类型的差异表现。我们的结论是,问责制,选择忽视学生的背景很可能会奖励和惩罚错误的学校,这将可能对学生的学习产生不利影响。这些发现,特别是当加上更普遍的关注周围的高风险测试和学校增值模式,提出了严重的怀疑,他们在学校问责制度的使用。

英文摘要:

In the UK, US and elsewhere, school accountability systems increasingly compare schools using value-added measures of school performance derived from pupil scores in high-stakes standardised tests. Rather than naively comparing school average scores, which largely reflect school intake differences in prior attainment, these measures attempt to compare the average progress or improvement pupils make during a year or phase of schooling. Schools, however, also differ in terms of their pupil demographic and socioeconomic characteristics and these also predict why some schools subsequently score higher than others. Many therefore argue that value-added measures unadjusted for pupil background are biased in favour of schools with more 'educationally advantaged' intakes. But, others worry that adjusting for pupil background entrenches socioeconomic inequities and excuses low performing schools. In this article we explore these theoretical arguments and their practical importance in the context of the 'Progress 8' secondary school accountability system in England which has chosen to ignore pupil background. We reveal how the reported low or high performance of many schools changes dramatically once adjustments are made for pupil background and these changes also affect the reported differential performances of region and of different school types. We conclude that accountability systems which choose to ignore pupil background are likely to reward and punish the wrong schools and this will likely have detrimental effects on pupil learning. These findings, especially when coupled with more general concerns surrounding high-stakes testing and school value-added models, raise serious doubts about their use in school accountability systems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑