“一无所有”:物理教育研究中零结果的意义
Nothing's plenty: The significance of null results in physics education research
摘要:
物理教育研究的一个中心目标是理解学习的过程,并利用这种理解来指导教学。为此,研究人员经常进行研究,以衡量课堂干预对学生学习成果的影响。许多这些干预研究提供了一个改革的教学技术,如积极参与的经验基础。然而,很多时候并没有足够的证据来证明干预措施达到了预期的效果,这些无效的结果往往最终被束之高阁。在本文中,我们认为零结果可以对物理教育研究做出重大贡献,即使结果在统计上不显着。首先,我们回顾了社会科学和生物医学研究,发现了广泛的出版物对无效结果的偏见,探讨为什么会发生这种情况,以及它是如何伤害该领域的。然后,我们提出了三个案例,从物理教育研究,以强调如何研究,产生无效的结果,可以有助于我们的教学和学习的理解。最后,我们从这些研究中提炼出一些从零结果中学习的一般原则,建议我们不应该根据它们是否拒绝零假设来评估它们,而是根据它们产生新理解的潜力。
英文摘要:
A central aim of physics education research is to understand the processes of learning and use that understanding to inform instruction. To this end, researchers often conduct studies to measure the effect of classroom interventions on student learning outcomes. Many of these intervention studies have provided an empirical foundation of reformed teaching techniques, such as active engagement. However, many times there is not sufficient evidence to conclude that the intervention had the intended effect, and these null results often end up in the file drawer. In this paper, we argue that null results can contribute significantly to physics education research, even if the results are not statistically significant. First, we review social sciences and biomedical research that has found widespread publication bias against null results, exploring why it occurs and how it can hurt the field. We then present three cases from physics education research to highlight how studies that yield null results can contribute to our understanding of teaching and learning. Finally, we distill from these studies some general principles for learning from null results, proposing that we should evaluate them not on whether they reject the null hypothesis, but according to their potential for generating new understanding.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。