arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1810.02689cs.CYcs.AI
收藏

人工智能用于公共部门决策的方式和原因:解释和评估

Hows and Whys of Artificial Intelligence for Public Sector Decisions: Explanation and Evaluation

Crime and Security Research Institute(犯罪与安全研究院);Cardiff University(卡迪夫大学);Y Lab(Y实验室);Nesta(内斯塔);IBM Research(IBM研究院)

Alun Preece, Rob Ashelford, Harry Armstrong, Dave Braines

摘要:

评估一直是基于人工智能(AI)的软件开发中的一个关键挑战,这是由于软件工件的技术复杂性,并且通常嵌入在复杂的社会技术过程中。由深度神经网络实现的机器学习(ML)的最新进展加剧了评估此类软件的挑战,因为这些基于ML的工件具有不透明的性质。一个关键的相关问题是(在)这样的系统产生有用的解释,他们的输出的能力,我们认为,解释和评价问题是密切相关的。本文在涉及人工智能和人类智能的公共部门决策(PSD)应用的背景下对基于ML的AI系统的元素进行建模,并将这些元素映射到评估和解释中的问题,显示两者之间的关系。我们考虑了一些常见的PSD应用模式,根据我们的模型,并确定了一组关键问题连接到每种情况下的解释和评估。最后,我们提出了多种策略来促进PSD中AI/ML技术的广泛采用,其中每种策略都以关注我们模型的不同元素为特征,使PSD政策制定者能够采用最适合其背景和关注点的方法。

英文摘要:

Evaluation has always been a key challenge in the development of artificial intelligence (AI) based software, due to the technical complexity of the software artifact and, often, its embedding in complex sociotechnical processes. Recent advances in machine learning (ML) enabled by deep neural networks has exacerbated the challenge of evaluating such software due to the opaque nature of these ML-based artifacts. A key related issue is the (in)ability of such systems to generate useful explanations of their outputs, and we argue that the explanation and evaluation problems are closely linked. The paper models the elements of a ML-based AI system in the context of public sector decision (PSD) applications involving both artificial and human intelligence, and maps these elements against issues in both evaluation and explanation, showing how the two are related. We consider a number of common PSD application patterns in the light of our model, and identify a set of key issues connected to explanation and evaluation in each case. Finally, we propose multiple strategies to promote wider adoption of AI/ML technologies in PSD, where each is distinguished by a focus on different elements of our model, allowing PSD policy makers to adopt an approach that best fits their context and concerns.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑