arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1808.07949q-fin.CP
收藏

黑魔法调查变得简单:使用FRACTI模式的动量交叉策略的蒙特卡罗模拟和历史回溯测试

Black Magic Investigation Made Simple: Monte Carlo Simulations and Historical Back Testing of Momentum Cross-Over Strategies Using FRACTI Patterns

Jorge Faleiro, Edward Tsang

摘要:

为了促进经济稳定,金融应该作为一门硬科学来研究,在那里应用科学方法。当一个交易策略被提出时,基础模型应该是透明的,并且定义得很好,以便其他研究人员能够彻底地理解和检查它。像任何硬科学一样,结果必须是可重复的,以便研究人员能够合作,并建立在彼此的结果基础上。大规模的合作,在应用科学调查的步骤时,是利用“人群科学”加速金融研究的有效途径。在本文中,我们展示了如何解决经济学中的一个现实问题,一个仍然存在很多争论的老问题,可以通过应用群体动力,协作科学计算框架来解决,完全支持现代科学方法所规定的调查过程。本文提供了一个真正的端到端调查示例来说明该框架的使用。我们特意选择了一个独立、完整、简单、易于理解的例子,这个例子在学术界和业界都引起了持续的争论:技术分析中常用的一种交易策略的表现。技术分析中的效率声称,被一些消息来源嘲笑为“黑魔法”,在主流媒体中广泛使用,通常会遇到很多争议。在本文中,我们表明,不同的研究人员评估这一战略不同,随后的辩论是由于缺乏方法比目的。报告的大多数结果是不可重复的其他研究人员。如果我们打算把金融学当作一门硬科学来对待,这是不令人满意的。为了平衡现状,我们展示了通过使用贡献的协作和调查功能以及利用群体的力量可以做些什么。

英文摘要:

To promote economic stability, finance should be studied as a hard science, where scientific methods apply. When a trading strategy is proposed, the underlying model should be transparent and defined robustly to allow other researchers to understand and examine it thoroughly. Like any hard sciences, results must be repeatable to allow researchers to collaborate, and build upon each other's results. Large-scale collaboration, when applying the steps of scientific investigation, is an efficient way to leverage "crowd science" to accelerate research in finance. In this paper, we demonstrate how a real world problem in economics, an old problem still subject to a lot of debate, can be solved by the application of a crowd-powered, collaborative scientific computational framework, fully supporting the process of investigation dictated by the modern scientific method. This paper provides a real end-to-end example of investigation to illustrate the use of the framework. We intentionally selected an example that is self-contained, complete, simple, accessible, and of constant debate in both academia and the industry: the performance of a trading strategy used commonly in technical analysis. Claims of efficiency in technical analysis, referred derisively by some sources as "Black Magic", are of widespread use in mainstream media and usually met with a lot of controversy. In this paper we show that different researchers assess this strategy differently, and the subsequent debate is due more to the lack of method than purpose. Most results reported are not repeatable by other researchers. This is not satisfactory if we intend to approach finance as a hard science. To counterweight the status quo, we demonstrate what one could do by using collaborative and investigative features of contributions and leveraging the power of crowds.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑