arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1808.07861stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

论气候变化影响研究中的模型选择准则

On model selection criteria for climate change impact studies

Xiaomeng Cui, Bulat Gafarov, Dalia Ghanem, Todd Kuffner

AI总结:

针对气候变化损害函数的政策评估目标,本文提出PWMSE模型选择准则,通过对未来气候的历史天气类比年份加权,选择在预计未来气候下预测影响误差最小的近似回归模型。

摘要:

气候变化影响研究向政策制定者提供未来气候变化对经济、健康及其他结果的预计损害信息。在大多数研究中,会观测到年度结果变量(例如农业产量)以及更高频的回归变量(例如每日气温)。随后,应用研究者面临一个模型选择问题:需要刻画结果变量与高频回归变量之间的非线性关系,以便依据模型所隐含的损害函数提出政策建议。我们表明,只有在所考虑的某个模型嵌套真实模型时,现有模型选择准则才适合该政策目标。如果所有模型都被视为对真实非线性关系的不完美近似,那么在正常气候条件下表现良好的模型,并不能保证在不同于历史常态的预计未来气候下也表现良好。因此,我们提出一种新的准则,即邻近加权均方误差(proximity-weighted mean-squared error,PWMSE),其直接以损害函数在预计未来气候处的精度为目标。为使该准则可行,在使用PWMSE评估相互竞争的模型时,我们对可作为预计未来气候天气类比的既往年份赋予更高权重。我们证明,我们的方法会选择最佳近似回归模型,该模型在预计未来气候下的预测影响加权误差最小。一项模拟研究以及一项重新审视气候变化对农业生产影响的应用,说明了我们理论分析的实证相关性。

英文摘要:

Climate change impact studies inform policymakers on the estimated damages of future climate change on economic, health and other outcomes. In most studies, an annual outcome variable is observed, e.g. agricultural yield, along with a higher-frequency regressor, e.g. daily temperature. Applied researchers then face a problem of selecting a model to characterize the nonlinear relationship between the outcome and the high-frequency regressor to make a policy recommendation based on the model-implied damage function. We show that existing model selection criteria are only suitable for the policy objective if one of the models under consideration nests the true model. If all models are seen as imperfect approximations to the true nonlinear relationship, the model that performs well in the normal climate conditions is not guaranteed to perform well at the projected climate that is different from the historical norm. We therefore propose a new criterion, the proximity-weighted mean-squared error (PWMSE), that directly targets precision of the damage function at the projected future climate. To make this criterion feasible, we assign higher weights to prior years that can serve as weather analogs to the projected future climate when evaluating competing models using the PWMSE. We show that our approach selects the best approximate regression model that has the smallest weighted error of predicted impacts for a projected future climate. A simulation study and an application revisiting the impact of climate change on agricultural production illustrate the empirical relevance of our theoretical analysis.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑