arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1807.11477econ.GNphysics.soc-phq-bio.PEq-fin.EC
收藏

不平等加剧和经济衰退下的两极分化

Polarization under rising inequality and economic decline

Alexander J. Stewart, Nolan McCarty, Joanna J. Bryson

摘要:

社会和政治两极分化是许多社会冲突和治理不善的重要根源。因此,了解其原因已成为许多学科学者的优先事项。在这里,我们证明,类似于政治极化和身份政治的社会化战略的转变,可以作为对财富不平等加剧和经济衰退的本地有益的反应。采用文化进化的视角,我们开发了一个框架来研究在不断变化的经济环境下两极分化的出现。在许多情况下,与不同的外群体互动,比只与同质的内群体互动,更能从创新和探索中获益。然而,当经济环境有利于风险规避时,寻求低风险互动的策略对维持个人偿付能力很重要。为了捕捉这种动态,我们假设组内互动的预期结果较低,但更确定。因此,群体内互动的风险比群体外互动的风险要小。我们的模型表明,在经济衰退或财富不平等加剧的情况下,一些人口成员从采取风险规避、群体内偏好策略中受益。此外,我们表明,这种群体内极化可以迅速蔓延到整个人口,并持续存在,即使产生它的条件已经逆转。最后,我们提供了经验支持的作用,收入不平等的情感两极分化的驱动程序在美国,镜像的发达民主国家的面板上的结果。我们的工作提供了一个框架,研究不同的力量如何相互作用,通过文化演变,塑造身份模式,并统一了什么往往被视为政治两极分化的相互矛盾的解释:身份威胁与经济焦虑。

英文摘要:

Social and political polarization is a significant source of conflict and poor governance in many societies. Thus, understanding its causes has become a priority of scholars across many disciplines. Here we demonstrate that shifts in socialization strategies analogous to political polarization and identity politics can arise as a locally-beneficial response to both rising wealth inequality and economic decline. Adopting a perspective of cultural evolution, we develop a framework to study the emergence of polarization under shifting economic environments. In many contexts, interacting with diverse out-groups confers benefits from innovation and exploration greater than those that arise from interacting exclusively with a homogeneous in-group. However, when the economic environment favors risk-aversion, a strategy of seeking low-risk interactions can be important to maintaining individual solvency. To capture this dynamic, we assume that in-group interactions have a lower expected outcome, but a more certain one. Thus in-group interactions are less risky than out-group interactions. Our model shows that under conditions of economic decline or increasing wealth inequality, some members of the population benefit from adopting a risk-averse, in-group favoring strategy. Moreover, we show that such in-group polarization can spread rapidly to the whole population and persist even when the conditions that produced it have reversed. Finally we offer empirical support for the role of income inequality as a driver of affective polarization in the United States, mirroring findings on a panel of developed democracies. Our work provides a framework for studying how disparate forces interplay, via cultural evolution, to shape patterns of identity, and unifies what are often seen as conflicting explanations for political polarization: identity threat versus economic anxiety.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑