沟通中的劳动分工:演讲者帮助听众解释视觉视角的不对称性
The division of labor in communication: Speakers help listeners account for asymmetries in visual perspective
摘要:
最近关于成年人心理理论使用的争论因交流中观点采择的意外失败而加剧,这表明观点采择可能相对费力。那么,演讲者和听众应该如何分配他们的资源来实现成功的沟通呢?我们首先观察到,这种共同的目标会导致自然的劳动分工:一个代理人选择分配给观点采择的资源应该取决于他们对另一个分配的期望。我们正式这个想法在一个资源合理的模型,增加最近的概率加权帐户的机制(昂贵的)控制程度的观点。在一系列的模拟中,我们首先推导出一个中间程度的观点权重作为预期的成本和利益的观点之间的最佳权衡。然后,我们提出了两个行为实验测试我们的模型的新的预测。在实验1中,我们操纵的存在或不存在的闭塞的导演匹配任务,发现扬声器自发地产生更多的信息描述占“已知的未知”在他们的合作伙伴的私人视图。在实验2中,我们比较了脚本的话语所使用的同盟者在以前的工作中产生的互动与unscripted董事。我们发现,邦联系统的信息量比听众最初预期的闭塞的存在,但听众使用的违规行为,以适应随着时间的推移,使更少的错误。总的来说,我们的研究表明,人们不仅仅是“头脑失明”;他们使用上下文适当的期望来导航与他们的合作伙伴的劳动分工。我们讨论了如何资源合理的框架可以提供一个更深入的解释基础,理解灵活的视角下处理的限制。
英文摘要:
Recent debates over adults' theory of mind use have been fueled by surprising failures of perspective-taking in communication, suggesting that perspective-taking can be relatively effortful. How, then, should speakers and listeners allocate their resources to achieve successful communication? We begin with the observation that this shared goal induces a natural division of labor: the resources one agent chooses to allocate toward perspective-taking should depend on their expectations about the other's allocation. We formalize this idea in a resource-rational model augmenting recent probabilistic weighting accounts with a mechanism for (costly) control over the degree of perspective-taking. In a series of simulations, we first derive an intermediate degree of perspective weighting as an optimal tradeoff between expected costs and benefits of perspective-taking. We then present two behavioral experiments testing novel predictions of our model. In Experiment 1, we manipulated the presence or absence of occlusions in a director-matcher task and found that speakers spontaneously produced more informative descriptions to account for "known unknowns" in their partner's private view. In Experiment 2, we compared the scripted utterances used by confederates in prior work with those produced in interactions with unscripted directors. We found that confederates were systematically less informative than listeners would initially expect given the presence of occlusions, but listeners used violations to adaptively make fewer errors over time. Taken together, our work suggests that people are not simply "mindblind"; they use contextually appropriate expectations to navigate the division of labor with their partner. We discuss how a resource rational framework may provide a more deeply explanatory foundation for understanding flexible perspective-taking under processing constraints.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。