机器学习分类器并不能改善学术风险的预测:来自澳大利亚的证据
Machine Learning Classifiers Do Not Improve the Prediction of Academic Risk: Evidence from Australia
摘要:
机器学习方法在预测方面往往优于传统的统计模型。在学术成就的预测中,ML模型并没有表现出比逻辑斯谛回归有实质性的改进。到目前为止,由于管理数据集的可用性,这些结果几乎完全集中在大学成绩上,并且按照ML标准包含相对较小的样本量。在本文中,我们将流行的机器学习模型应用于一个大型数据集($n=1.2$百万),该数据集包含澳大利亚学生每年进行的标准化考试中的小学和中学成绩。我们发现,机器学习模型并不优于逻辑斯谛回归检测学生谁将在“低于标准”的成绩带坐在他们的下一次测试,即使在一个大的$n$设置。
英文摘要:
Machine learning methods tend to outperform traditional statistical models at prediction. In the prediction of academic achievement, ML models have not shown substantial improvement over logistic regression. So far, these results have almost entirely focused on college achievement, due to the availability of administrative datasets, and have contained relatively small sample sizes by ML standards. In this article we apply popular machine learning models to a large dataset ($n=1.2$ million) containing primary and middle school performance on a standardized test given annually to Australian students. We show that machine learning models do not outperform logistic regression for detecting students who will perform in the `below standard' band of achievement upon sitting their next test, even in a large-$n$ setting.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。