悬崖之下隐藏着荒谬?没有时空的理论与科学理解
A Precipice Below Which Lies Absurdity? Theories without a Spacetime and Scientific Understanding
摘要:
虽然可视化与科学理解之间的关系一直是一个长期讨论的话题,但物理学的最新发展将这一争论的边界推向了新的、尚未探索的领域。因为有人声称,在某些量子引力理论中,时空“消失”了:这就意味着,人们可能有一些合理的物理理论,其中时空是完全不存在的。这使得哲学问题是否这些理论是可理解的,甚至更加紧迫。如果这些理论是可以理解的,那么问题是它们是如何做到的。在本文中,我们调整了科学理解的语境理论,由我们中的一个人开发,以适应没有时空的物理理论所带来的新挑战。我们认为理解是一种技能而不仅仅是知识。因此,我们的诉求是理解,而不是解释,因为我们关心的是科学家用来理解这些理论的工具。我们的中心论点是,这样的物理理论可以提供科学的理解,而这种理解不需要任何形式的时空。我们的论证由四个连续的步骤组成:(a)我们从科学理解的一般理论出发,论证了尽管形象化是理解的一个常用工具,但它不是理解的必要条件;(b)我们批评了某些形而上学的先入之见,这些先入之见可能妨碍我们认识到没有时空如何能够获得可理解性;(3)我们对没有时空的理论进行了分类,并列举了一些可以理解的工具;(4)我们给出了一些例子,说明了在没有时空的情况下也可以理解理论,并解释了这些例子提供了什么样的理解。
英文摘要:
While the relation between visualization and scientific understanding has been a topic of long-standing discussion, recent developments in physics have pushed the boundaries of this debate to new and still unexplored realms. For it is claimed that, in certain theories of quantum gravity, spacetime 'disappears': and this suggests that one may have sensible physical theories in which spacetime is completely absent. This makes the philosophical question whether such theories are intelligible, even more pressing. And if such theories are intelligible, the question then is how they manage to do so. In this paper, we adapt the contextual theory of scientific understanding, developed by one of us, to fit the novel challenges posed by physical theories without spacetime. We construe understanding as a matter of skill rather than just knowledge. The appeal is thus to understanding, rather than explanation, because we will be concerned with the tools that scientists have at their disposal for understanding these theories. Our central thesis is that such physical theories can provide scientific understanding, and that such understanding does not require spacetimes of any sort. Our argument consists of four consecutive steps: (a) We argue, from the general theory of scientific understanding, that although visualization is an oft-used tool for understanding, it is not a necessary condition for it; (b) we criticise certain metaphysical preconceptions which can stand in the way of recognising how intelligibility without spacetime can be had; (c) we catalogue tools for rendering theories without a spacetime intelligible; and (d) we give examples of cases in which understanding is attained without a spacetime, and explain what kind of understanding these examples provide.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。