加拿大时间分配委员会望远镜提案中的性别分类系统学
Sex-Disaggregated Systematics in Canadian Time Allocation Committee Telescope Proposal Reviews
摘要:
最近的研究表明,各种组织用来分配天文望远镜时间的建议同行评审过程产生的结果是系统性的偏见,这取决于建议的主要研究者(PI)是男性还是女性。使用加拿大-法国-夏威夷望远镜(CFHT)和双子座天文台的建议统计数据从加拿大超过10个最近的建议周期,我们评估是否平均建议分数分配的国家研究委员会(NRC)加拿大时间分配委员会(CanTAC)也与PI性别显着相关。经典的t检验、自助法和折刀重复法表明,女性提交的提案比男性提交的提案得到的评价要差得多。我们细分的数据,以调查按性别分列的统计数据有关PI职业生涯阶段(教师与非教师),望远镜要求,科学审查小组,观察学期,和博士一年的教师PI。与双变量结果一致,控制其他协变量的多元回归分析证实,PI性别是唯一显着的预测提案评分的样本作为一个整体,虽然出现的差异提交的建议由教师和非教师PI。虽然需要进一步的研究来解释我们的结果,但可能是内隐社会认知在起作用。NRC和CanTAC已采取措施减少这种可能性,改变提案作者名单,以便在共同调查者中隐藏PI的身份。我们建议,这一措施对减轻偏见的影响,在未来的观察学期进行定量评估,使用统计技术,如这里所采用的。
英文摘要:
Recent studies have shown that the proposal peer review processes employed by a variety of organizations to allocate astronomical telescope time produce outcomes that are systematically biased depending on whether proposal's principal investigator (PI) is a man or a woman. Using Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope (CFHT) and Gemini Observatory proposal statistics from Canada over 10 recent proposal cycles, we assess whether or not the mean proposal scores assigned by the National Research Council's (NRC's) Canadian Time Allocation Committee (CanTAC) also correlate significantly with PI sex. Classical t-tests, bootstrap and jackknife replications show that proposals submitted by women were rated significantly worse than those submitted by men. We subdivide the data in order to investigate sex-disaggregated statistics in relation to PI career stage (faculty vs. non-faculty), telescope requested, scientific review panel, observing semester, and the PhD year of faculty PIs. Consistent with the bivariate results, a multivariate regression analysis controlling for other covariates confirmed that PI sex is the only significant predictor of proposal rating scores for the sample as a whole, although differences emerge for proposals submitted by faculty and non-faculty PIs. While further research is needed to explain our results, it is possible that implicit social cognition is at work. NRC and CanTAC have taken steps to mitigate this possibility by altering proposal author lists in order to conceal the PI's identity among co-investigators. We recommend that the impact of this measure on mitigating bias in future observing semesters be quantitatively assessed using statistical techniques such as those employed here.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。