arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1805.06216math.LOcs.LO
收藏

Drinker Paragraph及其对偶

The Drinker Paradox and its Dual

Louis Warren, Hannes Diener, Maarten McKubre-Jordens

摘要:

饮酒者的行为如下。在每一个非空的酒馆里,都有一个人,如果那个人在喝酒,那么酒馆里的每个人都在喝酒。形式上,\[ \exists x \big(φ\rightarrow \forall y φ[x/y]\big) \ . \]由于其违反直觉的性质,它被称为悖论,即使它实际上是一个经典的重言式。然而,它不是最低限度(甚至直觉上)可证明的。其对偶也是如此,这(相当于)众所周知的\emph{independence of premise}原理,即\[ φ\rightarrow \exists x ψ \ \vdash \ \exists x (φ\rightarrow ψ) \],其中$x$在$φ$中不是自由的。在本文中,我们研究的影响,增加这些和其他公式图式的最小逻辑。我们首先表明,这些原则是独立的排中律和对方,第二,这些图式如何与其他知名的原则,如马尔可夫的无界搜索原则,提供证据和语义模型在适当的地方。

英文摘要:

The Drinker Paradox is as follows. In every nonempty tavern, there is a person such that if that person is drinking, then everyone in the tavern is drinking. Formally, \[ \exists x \big(φ\rightarrow \forall y φ[x/y]\big) \ . \] Due to its counterintuitive nature it is called a paradox, even though it actually is a classical tautology. However, it is not minimally (or even intuitionistically) provable. The same can be said of its dual, which is (equivalent to) the well-known principle of \emph{independence of premise}, \[ φ\rightarrow \exists x ψ \ \vdash \ \exists x (φ\rightarrow ψ) \] where $x$ is not free in $φ$. In this paper we study the implications of adding these and other formula schemata to minimal logic. We show first that these principles are independent of the law of excluded middle and of each other, and second how these schemata relate to other well-known principles, such as Markov's Principle of unbounded search, providing proofs and semantic models where appropriate.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑