arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1804.08646stat.MLcs.LG
收藏

保证科学结果稳健性的统计推断理论

A Theory of Statistical Inference for Ensuring the Robustness of Scientific Results

Harvard University(哈佛大学);Duke University(杜克大学)

Beau Coker, Cynthia Rudin, Gary King

摘要:

推理是利用我们已知的事实来了解我们不知道的事实的过程。推理理论给出了从前者到后者所必需的假设,以及由此产生的不确定性的定义和总结。任何一种推理理论都没有对错之分,而仅仅是一个可能有用也可能无用的公理。许多不同的推理理论中的每一种都对某些应用有价值。然而,没有现有的推理理论解决的倾向,选择的范围内合理的数据分析规范与先前的证据一致,那些无意中有利于自己的假设。由于这些选择的偏见是一个越来越多的关注跨科学领域,在某种意义上的原因,科学界被发明摆在首位,我们介绍了一个新的推理理论,旨在解决这个关键问题。我们引入黑客间隔,这是一个汇总统计的范围内,可以得到一类可能的内源性操作的数据。黑客间隔不需要诉诸从想象的超种群中提取的假设数据集。一个小的黑客间隔的科学结果是更强大的研究人员操纵比一个更大的间隔,往往比经典的置信区间更容易解释。一些版本的黑客区间被证明是等同于经典的置信区间,这意味着他们也可以提供一个更直观的和潜在的更有用的解释经典的置信区间。

英文摘要:

Inference is the process of using facts we know to learn about facts we do not know. A theory of inference gives assumptions necessary to get from the former to the latter, along with a definition for and summary of the resulting uncertainty. Any one theory of inference is neither right nor wrong, but merely an axiom that may or may not be useful. Each of the many diverse theories of inference can be valuable for certain applications. However, no existing theory of inference addresses the tendency to choose, from the range of plausible data analysis specifications consistent with prior evidence, those that inadvertently favor one's own hypotheses. Since the biases from these choices are a growing concern across scientific fields, and in a sense the reason the scientific community was invented in the first place, we introduce a new theory of inference designed to address this critical problem. We introduce hacking intervals, which are the range of a summary statistic one may obtain given a class of possible endogenous manipulations of the data. Hacking intervals require no appeal to hypothetical data sets drawn from imaginary superpopulations. A scientific result with a small hacking interval is more robust to researcher manipulation than one with a larger interval, and is often easier to interpret than a classical confidence interval. Some versions of hacking intervals turn out to be equivalent to classical confidence intervals, which means they may also provide a more intuitive and potentially more useful interpretation of classical confidence intervals.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑