arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1804.03519physics.gen-ph
收藏

Ia型超新星和伽马射线暴哈勃图的分析。两种模型的比较

Analysis of the Hubble diagram of type SNe Ia supernovae and of gamma-ray bursts. A comparison between two models

Jean-Marie Vigoureux, Dorian Vigoureux, Pierre Vigoureux, Michel Langlois

摘要:

Harmut Traunmüller的一篇论文[1]通过对观测数据的统计研究表明,最适合代表892颗1a型超新星的星等和红移观测的方程是$μ= 5\,log[(1+z)\,ln(1+z)] + const.$。将根据280颗超新星的观测红移数据计算的哈勃图与根据z = 0.0104至8.1范围内的两个宇宙学模型推导的哈勃图进行比较,Laszlo Marosi [2]在一项相当独立的研究中发现,表示观察结果的最佳拟合函数是$μ= 44.109769 \,z^{0.059883}$。注意到不同宇宙学模型之间的差异在光子飞行时间$t_s$与$z$表示中变得更加明显,他还指出,解释观测的最佳方程也可以写成$z = -1+e^{2.024\,\,10^{-18} \,\,ts}$。根据这些观测数据,我们将用平坦$ΛCDM$模型得到的理论哈勃图与几年前我们从一个模型得到的理论哈勃图进行比较[3,4,5],为了清楚起见,我们在这里称之为“光模型”。我们的结论是,根据$ΛCDM$模型计算的值与目前可用的数据不一致,而光模型与统计研究[1]和[2]的观察和结论完全一致(与$Ω_k$、$Ω_M$或$Ω_Λ$的值无关)。我们的模型没有给出宇宙的加速膨胀,我们得出结论,后者是不必要的,模型可以存在,而不必考虑宇宙的任何加速膨胀。在附录中,我们讨论了模型的一些方面,并简要概述了它的一些关键结果。

英文摘要:

A paper by Harmut Traunmüller [1] showed from statistical studies of observational data that the most adequate equation to represent observations on magnitude and redshift from 892 type 1a supernovae is $μ= 5\,log[(1+z)\,ln(1+z)] + const.$ Comparing the Hubble diagram calculated from the observed redshift data of 280 supernovae with Hubble diagrams inferred on the basis of two cosmological models in the range of z = 0.0104 to 8.1, Laszlo Marosi [2] found in a quite independant study that the best fit function to represent observations is $μ= 44.109769 \,z^{0.059883}$. Noting that differences between the different cosmological models become more pronouced in a photon time-of-fligth $t_s$ vs. $z$ représentation, he also noted that the best equation to account for observations may also be written $z = -1+e^{2.024\,\,10^{-18} \,\,ts}$. In the light of these observational data, we compare the theoretical Hubble diagram obtained with the flat $ΛCDM$ model to the ones we have obtained few years ago [3, 4, 5] from a model that we call here the "light model" for the sake of clarity. Our conclusions are that values calculated on the basis of the $ΛCDM$ model exhibit poor agreement with the presently available data while the light model agrees exactly with observations and conclusions of statistical studies [1] and [2] (independently of the values of $Ω_k$, $Ω_M$ or $Ω_Λ$). Our model giving no accelerating expansion of the universe, we conclude that this latter is not necessary and that models can exist which lead exactly to observations without having to consider any accelerating expansion of the universe. In an Appendix, we discuss some aspects of the model and we present a brief overview of some of its key results.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑