arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1802.08194physics.soc-phstat.APstat.OT
收藏

只见树木不见森林?网络知识调查

Seeing the forest for the trees? An investigation of network knowledge

Emily Breza, Arun G. Chandrasekhar, Alireza Tahbaz-Salehi

摘要:

本文评估了网络经济学文献中最流行的假设之一的实证内容,即假设决策者对他们互动的网络有充分的了解,使用来自75个村庄的网络数据,我们要求4,554个人评估他们村庄中随机选择的五对家庭是否通过金融,社会和信息关系联系在一起。我们发现,网络知识是低和高度本地化,急剧下降对的网络距离的受访者。46%的受访者甚至无法猜测一对个体之间潜在联系的状态。即使愿意提供猜测,受访者也只能在37%的时间内正确识别链接。我们还发现,社交距离的一步增加对应于错误识别链接的概率增加10个百分点。然后,我们研究了这一假设的理论意义,表明各种模型的预测发生了很大的变化,如果代理人的行为下更现实的假设,不完整的网络知识。总而言之,我们的研究结果表明,完整的网络知识的假设(i)可能是对现实世界的一个很差的近似,(ii)并不是无害的:允许不完整的网络知识可能会对各种背景下的一系列定性和定量结果产生一阶影响。

英文摘要:

This paper assesses the empirical content of one of the most prevalent assumptions in the economics of networks literature, namely the assumption that decision makers have full knowledge about the networks they interact on. Using network data from 75 villages, we ask 4,554 individuals to assess whether five randomly chosen pairs of households in their village are linked through financial, social, and informational relationships. We find that network knowledge is low and highly localized, declining steeply with the pair's network distance to the respondent. 46% of respondents are not even able to offer a guess about the status of a potential link between a given pair of individuals. Even when willing to offer a guess, respondents can only correctly identify the links 37% of the time. We also find that a one-step increase in the social distance to the pair corresponds to a 10pp increase in the probability of misidentifying the link. We then investigate the theoretical implications of this assumption by showing that the predictions of various models change substantially if agents behave under the more realistic assumption of incomplete knowledge about the network. Taken together, our results suggest that the assumption of full network knowledge (i) may serve as a poor approximation to the real world and (ii) is not innocuous: allowing for incomplete network knowledge may have first-order implications for a range of qualitative and quantitative results in various contexts.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑