论意义的根本性
On the Fundamentality of Meaning
摘要:
关于意义的主流观点是,它是涌现的,而不是根本的,但有些人对此提出异议,声称存在比当前物理理论所解决的更根本的现实水平,并且物质和意义在某种程度上是纠缠在一起的。在这方面,量子和生物学领域之间存在着有趣的相似之处,这表明两者可能都有一个更基本的层次。我认为,这个基本层次的组织已经在相当大的程度上被生物符号学家所理解,他们已经卓有成效地将皮尔士的符号理论整合到生物学中;那里发生的事情类似于熟悉的生活发生的事情,但是所涉及的机构在反映其基本性的方式上会有所不同,换句话说,它们将不那么复杂,但是仍然具有足够复杂的结构来完成它们必须做的事情。根据我参与的一个合作方法,他们必须做的一部分,以及生存和繁殖的需要,是阻止情况变得过于混乱,这一概念符合熟悉的“混乱边缘”思想。符号理论(semiophysics?)需要由物理学家来探索,可能的工具是计算模型,对复杂性的现有见解和动力系统理论。这样的理论将不会像传统物理学理论那样是数学的:数学不是基础,而是“生命所做的事情”,充分进化的生命所做的事情,因为在适当的环境中,这样做对生命有价值。
英文摘要:
The mainstream view of meaning is that it is emergent, not fundamental, but some have disputed this, asserting that there is a more fundamental level of reality than that addressed by current physical theories, and that matter and meaning are in some way entangled. In this regard there are intriguing parallels between the quantum and biological domains, suggesting that there may be a more fundamental level underlying both. I argue that the organisation of this fundamental level is already to a considerable extent understood by biosemioticians, who have fruitfully integrated Peirce's sign theory into biology; things will happen there resembling what happens with familiar life, but the agencies involved will differ in ways reflecting their fundamentality, in other words they will be less complex, but still have structures complex enough for what they have to do. According to one approach involving a collaboration with which I have been involved, a part of what they have to do, along with the need to survive and reproduce, is to stop situations becoming too chaotic, a concept that accords with familiar 'edge of chaos' ideas. Such an extension of sign theory (semiophysics?) needs to be explored by physicists, possible tools being computational models, existing insights into complexity, and dynamical systems theory. Such a theory will not be mathematical in the same way that conventional physics theories are mathematical: rather than being foundational, mathematics will be 'something that life does', something that sufficiently evolved life does because in the appropriate context so doing is of value to life.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。