基于格罗斯的无穷方法论与非标准分析的独立性以及对某些文本中逻辑谬误的评论
Independence of the grossone-based infinity methodology from non-standard analysis and comments upon logical fallacies in some texts asserting the opposite
摘要:
这篇评论考虑了非标准分析和最近引入的基于\G 1概念的计算方法(该符号称为\emph{grossone})。后一种方法的目的是让一个工作与无穷大和无穷小数值在一个独特的计算框架,并在所有的情况下,需要这些概念。非标准分析是一种经典的纯符号技术,适用于超滤波器,外部和内部集,标准和非标准数等,反过来,基于\G 1的方法不使用任何这些概念,并提出了一个更物理的处理数学对象分离的对象,用于研究它们的工具。它既提供了一种可能性,以创建新的数值方法使用无穷大和无穷小的浮点计算,并允许一个研究某些数学对象处理无穷大更准确地比它是传统的。在这些笔记中,我们解释说,即使这两种方法都处理无穷大和无穷小,它们是独立的,代表了两种不同的数学哲学,并不冲突。证明了文本\cite{Flunks, Gutman_Kutateladze_2008, Kutateladze_2011}断言,\G 1为基础的方法是一个非标准分析的一部分,不幸地包含几个逻辑谬误。他们试图证明基于\G 1的方法论是非标准分析的一部分,这类似于试图证明建构主义可以简化为传统的数学。
英文摘要:
This commentary considers non-standard analysis and a recently introduced computational methodology based on the notion of \G1 (this symbol is called \emph{grossone}). The latter approach was developed with the intention to allow one to work with infinities and infinitesimals numerically in a unique computational framework and in all the situations requiring these notions. Non-standard analysis is a classical purely symbolic technique that works with ultrafilters, external and internal sets, standard and non-standard numbers, etc. In its turn, the \G1-based methodology does not use any of these notions and proposes a more physical treatment of mathematical objects separating the objects from tools used to study them. It both offers a possibility to create new numerical methods using infinities and infinitesimals in floating-point computations and allows one to study certain mathematical objects dealing with infinity more accurately than it is done traditionally. In these notes, we explain that even though both methodologies deal with infinities and infinitesimals, they are independent and represent two different philosophies of Mathematics that are not in a conflict. It is proved that texts \cite{Flunks, Gutman_Kutateladze_2008, Kutateladze_2011} asserting that the \G1-based methodology is a part of non-standard analysis unfortunately contain several logical fallacies. Their attempt to prove that the \G1-based methodology is a part of non-standard analysis is similar to trying to show that constructivism can be reduced to the traditional mathematics.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。