arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1801.09848q-bio.NCcs.AIstat.ML
收藏

极端事件在决策中的过度表现:一个理性的元认知解释

Over-representation of Extreme Events in Decision-Making: A Rational Metacognitive Account

McGill University(麦吉尔大学)

Ardavan S. Nobandegani, Kevin da Silva Castanheira, A. Ross Otto, Thomas R. Shultz

摘要:

可用性偏差,表现为在决策中过度描述极端可能性,是一种众所周知的认知偏差,通常被视为人类非理性的证据。在这项工作中,我们提出了第一个合理的,元认知帐户的可用性偏见,正式阐述了马尔的算法水平的分析。具体地说,我们提出了一个规范的,元认知模型的认知系统应该如何过度代表极端的可能性,这取决于其可支配的决策时间。我们的模型还解释了人类风险决策中两个众所周知的框架效应--结果概率(Tversky & Kahneman,1992)和结果幅度(Markovitz,1952)中的风险偏好的四重模式--从而为这些效应提供了第一个元认知理性基础。此外,经验证据证实了我们模型的一个重要预测。令人惊讶的是,我们的模型是不可否认的强大相对于其焦点参数。我们讨论了我们的工作对人类决策研究的影响,最后提出了一个违反直觉的预测,我们的模型,如果得到证实,将有有趣的影响,人类决策的风险。据我们所知,我们的模型是第一个元认知,资源理性的认知偏见的决策过程模型。

英文摘要:

The Availability bias, manifested in the over-representation of extreme eventualities in decision-making, is a well-known cognitive bias, and is generally taken as evidence of human irrationality. In this work, we present the first rational, metacognitive account of the Availability bias, formally articulated at Marr's algorithmic level of analysis. Concretely, we present a normative, metacognitive model of how a cognitive system should over-represent extreme eventualities, depending on the amount of time available at its disposal for decision-making. Our model also accounts for two well-known framing effects in human decision-making under risk---the fourfold pattern of risk preferences in outcome probability (Tversky & Kahneman, 1992) and in outcome magnitude (Markovitz, 1952)---thereby providing the first metacognitively-rational basis for those effects. Empirical evidence, furthermore, confirms an important prediction of our model. Surprisingly, our model is unimaginably robust with respect to its focal parameter. We discuss the implications of our work for studies on human decision-making, and conclude by presenting a counterintuitive prediction of our model, which, if confirmed, would have intriguing implications for human decision-making under risk. To our knowledge, our model is the first metacognitive, resource-rational process model of cognitive biases in decision-making.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑