arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1801.05265math.OC
收藏

用综合指数聚合相互作用维度的强有力的可持续发展评估:分层-SMAA-Choquet积分方法

Robust sustainable development assessment with composite indices aggregating interacting dimensions: the hierarchical-SMAA-Choquet integral approach

Silvia Angilella, Pierluigi Catalfo, Salvatore Corrente, Alfio Giarlotta, Salvatore Greco, Marcella Rizzo

摘要:

通过综合指数评价可持续发展-特别是农村发展-需要考虑到与经济、社会和环境方面有关的多种指标。这些指数所评价的观点自然是相互作用的:因此,必须对在协同标准方面表现良好的单位给予奖励,而对冗余标准则给予惩罚。模型化的另一个困难是综合指数参数的确定,因为这些参数通常受到某些不精确性的影响。在大多数方法中,所有这些临界点通常被忽略,这反过来又在指数计算中产生令人不快的逼近阶。在本文中,我们提出了一种方法,允许一个同时处理这些微妙的问题。具体来说,考虑到标准之间的协同作用和冗余,我们适当地聚合指标的Choquet积分。此外,为了获得考虑到与非加性权重(Choquet积分的能力)中的不精确性相关的波动空间的建议,我们采用了稳健有序回归(ROR)和随机多准则可接受性分析(SMAA)。最后,为了不仅在综合层面(考虑所有标准)而且在地方层面(分别考虑经济,社会和环境方面)研究可持续性,我们应用了多标准层次过程(MCHP)。我们说明了我们的方法的优势,在一个具体的例子中,我们衡量的农村可持续发展的51个城市在卡塔尼亚省,西西里岛(意大利)东海岸最大的城市。

英文摘要:

The evaluation of sustainable development - and, in particular, rural development - through composite indices requires taking into account a plurality of indicators, which are related to economic, social and environmental aspects. The points of view evaluated by these indices are naturally interacting: thus, a bonus has to be recognized to units performing well on synergic criteria, whereas a penalization has to be assigned on redundant criteria. An additional difficulty of the modelization is the elicitation of the parameters for the composite indices, since they are typically affected by some imprecision. In most approaches, all these critical points are usually neglected, which in turn yields an unpleasant degree of approximation in the computation of indices. In this paper we propose a methodology that allows one to simultaneously handle these delicate issues. Specifically, to take into account synergy and redundancy between criteria, we suitably aggregate indicators by means of the Choquet integral. Further, to obtain recommendations that take into account the space of fluctuation related to imprecision in nonadditive weights (capacity of the Choquet integral), we adopt the Robust Ordinal Regression (ROR) and the Stochastic Multicriteria Acceptability Analysis (SMAA). Finally, to study sustainability not only at a comprehensive level (taking into account all criteria) but also at a local level (separately taking into account economic, social and environmental aspects), we apply the Multiple Criteria Hierarchy Process (MCHP). We illustrate the advantages of our approach in a concrete example, in which we measure the rural sustainability of 51 municipalities in the province of Catania, the largest city of the East Coast of Sicily (Italy).

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑