如何从五位数汇总中估计样本均值和标准差?
How to estimate the sample mean and standard deviation from the five number summary?
摘要:
在某些临床研究中,研究者可能报告5个数字汇总(包括样本中位数、第一和第三四分位数、最小值和最大值),而不是样本均值和标准差。要对汇总研究进行荟萃分析,首先需要从5个数字汇总中估计样本均值和标准差。在最近的文献中已经提出了一些研究来解决这个问题。然而,现有的标准差的估计是令人满意的实际使用。经过对现有文献的简要回顾,我们指出,万等。的方法(BMC Med Res Methodol 14:135,2014)在从五个数字总结估计标准差方面具有严重的局限性。为了改进它,我们提出了一个光滑加权估计,通过纳入样本量的信息,并推导出新的估计的最佳权重。为了便于实现,我们还提供了一个近似公式的最佳权重和一个快捷的公式估计的标准差从五个数字的总和。所提出的估计的性能进行评估,通过两个模拟研究。与Wan et al.的估计器,我们的新估计器提供了一个更准确的估计正常的数据,并表现出良好的非正常数据。在实际数据分析中,我们的新方法也能够提供比现有方法更准确的真实样本标准差的估计。本文提出了五数求和的标准差的一个最优估计。与Luo等人的最佳均值估计量(Stat Methods Med Res,出版中,2017)一起,我们的新方法改进了现有文献,并将为荟萃分析和循证医学做出坚实的贡献。
英文摘要:
In some clinical studies, researchers may report the five number summary (including the sample median, the first and third quartiles, and the minimum and maximum values) rather than the sample mean and standard deviation. To conduct meta-analysis for pooling studies, one needs to first estimate the sample mean and standard deviation from the five number summary. A number of studies have been proposed in the recent literature to solve this problem. However, none of the existing estimators for the standard deviation is satisfactory for practical use. After a brief review of the existing literature, we point out that Wan et al.'s method (BMC Med Res Methodol 14:135, 2014) has a serious limitation in estimating the standard deviation from the five number summary. To improve it, we propose a smoothly weighted estimator by incorporating the sample size information and derive the optimal weight for the new estimator. For ease of implementation, we also provide an approximation formula of the optimal weight and a shortcut formula for estimating the standard deviation from the five number summary. The performance of the proposed estimator is evaluated through two simulation studies. In comparison with Wan et al.'s estimator, our new estimator provides a more accurate estimate for normal data and performs favorably for non-normal data. In real data analysis, our new method is also able to provide a more accurate estimate of the true sample standard deviation than the existing method. In this paper, we propose an optimal estimator of the standard deviation from the five number summary. Together with the optimal mean estimator in Luo et al. (Stat Methods Med Res, in press, 2017), our new methods have improved the existing literature and will make a solid contribution to meta-analysis and evidence-based medicine.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。