arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1709.05079q-bio.PEq-bio.QM
收藏

探索密码子模型中缺乏闭合的后果

Exploring the consequences of lack of closure in codon models

Michael D. Woodhams, Jeremy G. Sumner, David A. Liberles, Michael A. Charleston, Barbara R. Holland

摘要:

密码子进化模型通常用于鉴定正选择。正选择通常是异质过程,即,它作用于进化树的某些分支而不是其他分支。以前的工作DNA模型表明,当进化发生在一个异构的过程中,重要的是要考虑模型的封闭性,因为非封闭的模型可以给有偏见的估计进化过程。现有的解释遗传密码的密码子模型不是封闭的;为了建立这一点,足以表明它们不是线性的(意味着模型中两个密码子速率矩阵的总和不是模型中的矩阵)。这引起了人们的关注,即适合异质过程的单个密码子模型可能错误估计选择和分支长度的影响。密码子模型通常通过选择基础DNA模型(例如,HKY),然后通过参数$ω$应用遗传密码以改变编码不同氨基酸的密码子之间的转换速率。在这里,我们使用模拟调查的选择参数$ω$和分支长度的情况下,其中潜在的DNA过程是异质的,但$ω$是恒定的估计的准确性。我们发现,在这些情况下,$ω$和分支长度可以被错误估计。$ω$的误差通常小于2%,但可能高达17%。我们还评估了选择不同的基础DNA模型是否对准确性有任何影响,特别是我们评估了使用封闭DNA模型是否有任何优势。然而,封闭的DNA模型并不意味着由其构建的密码子模型是封闭的,并且一般来说,我们发现使用封闭的DNA模型并没有减少$ω$估计中的错误。

英文摘要:

Models of codon evolution are commonly used to identify positive selection. Positive selection is typically a heterogeneous process, i.e., it acts on some branches of the evolutionary tree and not others. Previous work on DNA models showed that when evolution occurs under a heterogeneous process it is important to consider the property of model closure, because non-closed models can give biased estimates of evolutionary processes. The existing codon models that account for the genetic code are not closed; to establish this it is enough to show that they are not linear (meaning that the sum of two codon rate matrices in the model is not a matrix in the model). This raises the concern that a single codon model fit to a heterogeneous process might mis-estimate both the effect of selection and branch lengths. Codon models are typically constructed by choosing an underlying DNA model (e.g., HKY) that acts identically and independently at each codon position, and then applying the genetic code via the parameter $ω$ to modify the rate of transitions between codons that code for different amino acids. Here we use simulation to investigate the accuracy of estimation of both the selection parameter $ω$ and branch lengths in cases where the underlying DNA process is heterogeneous but $ω$ is constant. We find that both $ω$ and branch lengths can be mis-estimated in these scenarios. Errors in $ω$ were usually less than 2% but could be as high as 17%. We also assessed if choosing different underlying DNA models had any affect on accuracy, in particular we assessed if using closed DNA models gave any advantage. However, a DNA model being closed does not imply that the codon model constructed from it is closed, and in general we found that using closed DNA models did not decrease errors in the estimation of $ω$.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑