再分配与再分配:推理的比较
Reallocating and Resampling: A Comparison for Inference
摘要:
基于模拟的推理在现代统计学中扮演着重要的角色,并且经常使用重新分配(如随机化测试)或重新分配(如自举)。重新分配模拟随机分配到治疗组,而重新分配模拟从更大的人群中随机抽样;模拟方法是否与数据收集方法匹配是否重要?此外,测试与估计的结果是否不同?在这里,我们回答了这些问题,在一个简单的设置下,探索一个基本的两组设计和四种不同的情况下,平均值的样本差异的分布:真正的随机分配,真正的随机抽样,重新分配,和rescue。对于检验尖锐的原假设,重新分配在小样本中更优,但重新分配和重新分配是渐近等价的。对于估计,除非效果确实是累加的,否则Rescue通常是优越的。此外,无论数据是通过随机抽样还是随机分配收集的,这些结果都成立。
英文摘要:
Simulation-based inference plays a major role in modern statistics, and often employs either reallocating (as in a randomization test) or resampling (as in bootstrapping). Reallocating mimics random allocation to treatment groups, while resampling mimics random sampling from a larger population; does it matter whether the simulation method matches the data collection method? Moreover, do the results differ for testing versus estimation? Here we answer these questions in a simple setting by exploring the distribution of a sample difference in means under a basic two group design and four different scenarios: true random allocation, true random sampling, reallocating, and resampling. For testing a sharp null hypothesis, reallocating is superior in small samples, but reallocating and resampling are asymptotically equivalent. For estimation, resampling is generally superior, unless the effect is truly additive. Moreover, these results hold regardless of whether the data were collected by random sampling or random allocation.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。