布劳威尔和欧几里得
Brouwer and Euclid
摘要:
我们探讨了布劳威尔的直觉主义数学和欧几里德几何之间的关系。布劳威尔写了一篇论文在1949年所谓的“矛盾的初等几何”。在那篇论文中,他证明了平行公设的一个经典推论隐含了马尔可夫原理,他发现这是直觉上不可接受的。但是欧几里德的几何学,作为两千年来清晰而正确的推理的灯塔,并不是那么容易被抛弃的。布劳威尔从一个不在欧几里德中的“定理”开始,并需要马尔可夫原理来证明。这意味着布劳威尔的论文没有解决欧几里德的《几何原本》是否真的需要马尔可夫原理的问题。本文证明了存在一个“非马尔可夫欧氏几何”的相干理论。“我们在一些细节上表明,我们的理论是(至少)欧几里德第一卷的充分形式化的呈现,并且足以定义几何算术,从而完善了作者以前的研究(其中包括马尔可夫原理作为公理)。哲学上,布劳威尔的证明,他的版本的平行公设意味着马尔可夫的原则可以阅读以及几何证据的真理马尔可夫的原则,如果一个人认为几何“相交定理”与布劳威尔开始是几何明显的。
英文摘要:
We explore the relationship between Brouwer's intuitionistic mathematics and Euclidean geometry. Brouwer wrote a paper in 1949 called "The contradictority of elementary geometry". In that paper, he showed that a certain classical consequence of the parallel postulate implies Markov's principle, which he found intuitionistically unacceptable. But Euclid's geometry, having served as a beacon of clear and correct reasoning for two millenia, is not so easily discarded. Brouwer started from a "theorem" that is not in Euclid, and requires Markov's principle for its proof. That means that Brouwer's paper did not address the question whether Euclid's "Elements" really requires Markov's principle. In this paper we show that there is a coherent theory of "non-Markovian Euclidean geometry." We show in some detail that our theory is an adequate formal rendering of (at least) Euclid's Book~I, and suffices to define geometric arithmetic, thus refining the author's previous investigations (which include Markov's principle as an axiom). Philosophically, Brouwer's proof that his version of the parallel postulate implies Markov's principle could be read just as well as geometric evidence for the truth of Markov's principle, if one thinks the geometrical "intersection theorem" with which Brouwer started is geometrically evident.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。