大脑可控性的解释和警告
Warnings and Caveats in Brain Controllability
摘要:
在这项工作中,我们挑战的主要结论顾等人的工作(可控性的结构脑网络。Nature Communications 6,8414,doi:10.1038/ncomms9414,2015)。使用相同的方法和对四个数据集的分析,我们发现控制大脑网络的最小节点集总是大于1。我们还发现,平均/模态可控性和加权度之间的关系也适用于随机数据,并且静息状态网络在控制大脑方面没有发挥特定的作用。总之,我们表明,没有证据表明,拓扑结构在大脑网络的可控性发挥特定的和独特的作用。因此,应重新审视Gu等人对其结果的解释,特别是在平移应用方面(例如,使用单节点可控性属性来定义神经刺激的目标区域)。虽然理论上很有趣,但我们对可控性和结构脑网络之间关系的理解仍然难以捉摸。
英文摘要:
In this work we challenge the main conclusions of Gu et al work (Controllability of structural brain networks. Nature communications 6, 8414, doi:10.1038/ncomms9414, 2015) on brain controllability. Using the same methods and analyses on four datasets we find that the minimum set of nodes to control brain networks is always larger than one. We also find that the relationships between the average/modal controllability and weighted degrees also hold for randomized data and the there are not specific roles played by Resting State Networks in controlling the brain. In conclusion, we show that there is no evidence that topology plays specific and unique roles in the controllability of brain networks. Accordingly, Gu et al. interpretation of their results, in particular in terms of translational applications (e.g. using single node controllability properties to define target region(s) for neurostimulation) should be revisited. Though theoretically intriguing, our understanding of the relationship between controllability and structural brain network remains elusive.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。