arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1704.08758physics.class-ph
收藏

静电学中无限电荷分布问题的欺骗性简单性

The deceiving simplicity of problems with infinite charge distributions in electrostatics

Marcin Kościelecki, Piotr Nieżurawski

摘要:

我们表明,对于一个无限的,均匀带电的板没有明确定义的电场存在的静电学的框架,因为它不能被定义为一个有限的板的解决方案的数学上一致的限制。我们讨论一个无限的线和一个无限的条纹作为例子的无限电荷分布的电场可以确定为一个正式的,数学的方式限制。我们还提出了一个教学框架,可以帮助学生了解静电极限问题的微妙之处。该框架由启发式工具(索赔),有助于调整直觉的精神,严格定义的积分。我们彻底讨论了在何种程度上的有限板的解决方案同意传统的,但不幸的是不明确的解决方案的无限板。物理学是一门近似的科学。人们可能会问,如果数学上定义不清的公式和对象能使生活更简单,为什么要禁止使用它们呢?在我们看来,近似应该有坚实的物理和数学基础。

英文摘要:

We show that for an infinite, uniformly charged plate no well defined electric field exists in the framework of electrostatics, because it cannot be defined as a mathematically consistent limit of a solution for a finite plate. We discuss an infinite wire and an infinite stripe as examples of infinite charge distributions for which the electric field can be determined as a limit in a formal, mathematical way. We also propose a didactic framework that can help students understand subtleties related to the problems of limits in electrostatics. The framework consists of heuristic tools (claims) that help to align intuitions in the spirit of a rigorous definition of an integral. We thoroughly discuss to what degree the solution for a finite plate agrees with the traditional but unfortunately ill-defined solution for an infinite plate. Physics is a science of approximations. One can ask why the use of mathematically ill-defined formulae and objects should be forbidden if they make life simpler. In our opinion, approximations should have solid physical and mathematical foundations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑