当信心和能力发生冲突时:对在线决策讨论的影响
When confidence and competence collide: Effects on online decision-making discussions
摘要:
小组讨论是一种个人交流思想和论点的方式,以便比他们自己做出更好的决定。富有成效的讨论的前提之一是,更好的解决方案将占上风,而想法选择过程是由所涉及的个人的(相对)能力介导的。然而,由于人们可能不知道他们在一项新任务上的实际能力,他们的行为受到他们自我估计的能力的影响-也就是说,他们的信心-这可能与他们的实际能力不一致。我们在这项工作中的目标是了解信心-能力不一致对讨论的动态和结果的影响。为此,我们设计了一个大规模的自然环境,在一个在线团队为基础的地理游戏的形式,使我们能够解开能力的信心,从而分离它们的影响。我们发现,在以任务为导向的讨论中,更自信的个人对小组的决策有更大的影响,即使这些人与他们的队友处于相同的能力水平。此外,信心在决策过程中的这种不合理的作用往往导致团队表现不佳。我们通过调查信心对会话动态的影响来探索这一现象。
英文摘要:
Group discussions are a way for individuals to exchange ideas and arguments in order to reach better decisions than they could on their own. One of the premises of productive discussions is that better solutions will prevail, and that the idea selection process is mediated by the (relative) competence of the individuals involved. However, since people may not know their actual competence on a new task, their behavior is influenced by their self-estimated competence --- that is, their confidence --- which can be misaligned with their actual competence. Our goal in this work is to understand the effects of confidence-competence misalignment on the dynamics and outcomes of discussions. To this end, we design a large-scale natural setting, in the form of an online team-based geography game, that allows us to disentangle confidence from competence and thus separate their effects. We find that in task-oriented discussions, the more-confident individuals have a larger impact on the group's decisions even when these individuals are at the same level of competence as their teammates. Furthermore, this unjustified role of confidence in the decision-making process often leads teams to under-perform. We explore this phenomenon by investigating the effects of confidence on conversational dynamics.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。