突现与还原论:一个尴尬的培根联盟
Emergence and Reductionism: an awkward Baconian alliance
摘要:
本文从一个凝聚态物理学家的角度讨论了突现与还原论的关系。还原论和涌现在物理学家的日常生活中扮演着相互交织的角色,然而我们很少停下来思考它们的关系:事实上,这两者经常被认为是相互冲突的科学世界观。我认为,在实践中,他们互相恭维,形成了文艺复兴时期科学家弗朗西斯·培根所设想的尴尬联盟。通过研究经典物理学和量子物理学的历史记录,我讨论了自然的出现如何符合还原论的观点。通常,对还原论物理学的深刻理解取决于对其涌现结果的理解。因此,牛顿、莱布尼茨、拉格朗日和汉密尔顿都不知道能量的概念,因为他们不了解热。同样,对弱力的理解也需要对超导中的迈斯纳效应的理解。因此,涌现可以被比作简化论的加密结果。以当前研究中的例子,包括拓扑绝缘体和奇怪的金属,我表明,涌现和还原论之间的对流继续为前沿科学研究提供强大的驱动力,将实验室与宇宙联系起来。
英文摘要:
This article discusses the relationship between emergence and reductionism from the perspective of a condensed matter physicist. Reductionism and emergence play an intertwined role in the everyday life of the physicist, yet we rarely stop to contemplate their relationship: indeed, the two are often regarded as conflicting world-views of science. I argue that in practice, they compliment one-another, forming an awkward alliance in a fashion envisioned by the Renaissance scientist, Francis Bacon. Looking at the historical record in classical and quantum physics, I discuss how emergence fits into a reductionist view of nature. Often, a deep understanding of reductionist physics depends on the understanding of its emergent consequences. Thus the concept of energy was unknown to Newton, Leibnitz, Lagrange or Hamilton, because they did not understand heat. Similarly, the understanding of the weak force awaited an understanding of the Meissner effect in superconductivity. Emergence can thus be likened to an encrypted consequence of reductionism. Taking examples from current research, including topological insulators and strange metals, I show that the convection between emergence and reductionism continues to provide a powerful driver for frontier scientific research, linking the lab with the cosmos.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。