arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1701.05066math.LO
收藏

扭转形式主义16

Reverse Formalism 16

Sam Sanders

摘要:

在他著名的论文Formalism 64中,罗宾逊为他的哲学立场辩护如下:(1)任何提到无限总体的说法都是毫无意义的。(ii)我们应该表现得好像无限的整体真的存在。作为非标准分析的创始人,罗宾逊经常会面临这样一种对立的立场,即“一些无限的总体比其他的更有意义”,教科书上的例子就是无穷小(与争议较少的无限总体相比)。例如,毕晓普和康纳斯对无穷小和一般的非标准分析提出了这样的主张,甚至分别称后者为意义的贬低和虚的,同时接受其他无限总体和相关的数学框架为有意义的。我们将研究毕晓普和康纳斯对非标准分析的批评,并观察到这些作者将“意义”和“计算内容”等同起来,尽管他们对所说的内容的解释各不相同。正如我们将看到的,Bishop和Connes声称,非标准分析中理想对象(特别是无穷小)的存在导致了意义(即计算内容)的缺失。我们将通过建立相反的观点来揭穿Bishop-Connes的批判,即在非标准分析中理想对象(特别是无穷小)的存在产生了计算内容的普遍存在。特别是,无穷小提供了一个优雅的速记表示计算内容。为此,我们引入了一个直接的翻译之间的一大类定理的非标准分析和定理丰富的计算内容(不涉及非标准分析),类似于“逆转”的基础程序逆向数学。后者在衡量这一翻译的范围方面也起着重要作用。

英文摘要:

In his remarkable paper Formalism64, Robinson defends his philsophocal position as follows: (i) Any mention of infinite totalities is literally meaningless. (ii) We should act as if infinite totalities really existed. Being the originator of Nonstandard Analysis, it stands to reason that Robinson would have often been faced with the opposing position that 'some infinite totalities are more meaningful than others', the textbook example being that of infinitesimals (versus less controversial infinite totalities). For instance, Bishop and Connes have made such claims regarding infinitesimals, and Nonstandard Analysis in general, going as far as calling the latter respectively a debasement of meaning and virtual, while accepting as meaningful other infinite totalities and the associated mathematical framework. We shall study the critique of Nonstandard Analysis by Bishop and Connes, and observe that these authors equate 'meaning' and 'computational content', though their interpretations of said content vary. As we will see, Bishop and Connes claim that the presence of ideal objects (in particular infinitesimals) in Nonstandard Analysis yields the absence of meaning (i.e. computational content). We will debunk the Bishop-Connes critique by establishing the contrary, namely that the presence of ideal objects (in particular infinitesimals) in Nonstandard Analysis yields the ubiquitous presence of computational content. In particular, infinitesimals provide an elegant shorthand for expressing computational content. To this end, we introduce a direct translation be- tween a large class of theorems of Nonstandard Analysis and theorems rich in computational content (not involving Nonstandard Analysis), similar to the 'reversals' from the foundational program Reverse Mathematics. The latter also plays an important role in gauging the scope of this translation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑