arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1612.09595q-bio.PE
收藏

人属内形态特征的互补系统发育信号和定量三维形状数据

Complimentary Phylogenetic Signals for Morphological Characters and Quantitative 3D Shape Data within genus Homo

Peter J. Waddell

摘要:

估计人属的进化史正进入一个数据和方法大大改进的新阶段。越来越多的证据表明,在过去的50万年里,任何时候都有6到10个相互竞争的物种/谱系,这使得阐明个体标本之间的关系变得尤为重要。最近对关键标本的繁殖力的估计包括Waddell(2013,2014,2015,2016)和Mounier et al.(2016)。这些都是用完全不同的数据(分别是3D头骨形状和离散形态特征)和分析方法(分别是距离的未加权最小二乘拟合,OLS+和重新加权的最大简约性)。对这些文章中的树进行初步检查可能会留下大量不一致和混乱结果的印象。在这里,它表明这不一定是这种情况,这两种类型的数据和分析可能表明一个非常相似的树,一个是在良好的协议也与主观的当前智慧/专家意见的特定部分的遗传。非洲LH 18标本的精确位置是更好地理解H最后共同祖先可能形式的关键。智人和穴居人一个多样化的方法似乎带来了更多的协议的树木比其他感知,并反对教条主义的系统发育分析方法,特别是在处理困难的问题。

英文摘要:

Estimating the phylogeny of the genus Homo is entering a new phase of vastly improved data and methodology. There is increasing evidence of 6 to 10 competing species/lineages at any point in the last half million years, making the elucidation of the relationships of individual specimens particularly important. Recent estimates of the phylogeny of key specimens include Waddell (2013, 2014, 2015, 2016), and Mounier et al. (2016). These are made with quite different data (3D skull shapes and discrete morphological characters, respectively) and methods of analysis (unweighted least squares fitting of distances, OLS+, and reweighted maximum parsimony, respectively). Initial inspection of the trees in these articles might leave the impression of a great deal of disagreement and confused results. Here it is shown this need not be the case, and that these two types of data and analysis may be indicating a very similar tree, one that is in good agreement also with subjective current wisdom/expert opinions on particular parts of the phylogeny. The precise location of the African LH18 specimen arises as key to a better understanding of the likely form of the last common ancestors of H. sapiens and Neanderthals. A diverse approach seems to bring forth much more agreement of trees than otherwise perceived, and argues against being dogmatic about methods of phylogenetic analysis particularly when working with difficult problems.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑