arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1612.00481physics.chem-phphysics.atom-phquant-ph
收藏

对“关于“分子光电离中的时间延迟”的评论“的回应:扩展讨论和技术说明

Response to 'Comment on "Time delays in molecular photoionization"': Extended Discussion & Technical Notes

Paul Hockett, Eugene Frumker

摘要:

在对我们的文章“分子光电离中的时间延迟”[1]的评论中,Baykusheva和Wörner再现了正则散射理论,并断言我们的结果与这个公认的理论不一致[2]。我们绝对驳斥这种说法和评论的精神,尽管我们同意Baykusheva和Wörner的观点,即教科书理论是正确的。在一个简短的回应中,对“分子光电离中的时间延迟”的评论的回应[3],我们已经提供了对评论的明确反驳,但没有给出技术细节。在这个更全面的回应中,我们本着完整和清晰的精神扩展了这些简短的评论,并根据(1)逻辑谬误(类别错误),(2)原始文章的理论细节,(3)原始文章的文本内容,对Baykusheva & Wörner提出了三个明确的反驳。特别是,反驳(1)清楚而琐碎地指出了这样一个事实,即这里不存在任何问题,并诉诸于几乎不需要证明这一点的理论细节,正如我们的回应的简短版本所概述的那样。我们的数值结果是正确的,并再现已知的物理现象,在原来的文章中讨论,因此,作为细心的读者会认识到,所使用的形式主义是典型的散射理论,不能是其他任何东西。事实上,这里没有任何新的基础物理学可以争论,这也不是原始文章存在的理由。此外,反驳(2)提供了详细讨论光电离理论的一些教科书方面的机会,我们希望这种讨论可能对进入这个具有挑战性的领域的新研究人员有所帮助。

英文摘要:

In a comment on our article Time delays in molecular photoionization [1], Baykusheva & Wörner reproduce canonical scattering theory, and assert that our results are inconsistent with this well-established theory [2]. We absolutely refute this assertion and the spirit of the comment, although we do agree with Baykusheva & Wörner that the textbook theory is correct. In a short response, Response to Comment on "Time delays in molecular photoionization" [3], we have already provided a clear rebuttal of the comment, but gave no technical details. In this fuller response we extend those brief comments in the spirit of completeness and clarity, and provide three clear rebuttals to Baykusheva & Wörner based on (1) logical fallacy (category error), (2) theoretical details of the original article, (3) textural content of the original article. In particular, rebuttal (1) clearly and trivially points to the fact that there is no issue here whatsoever, with recourse to theoretical details barely required to demonstrate this, as outlined in the short version of our response. Our numerical results are correct and reproduce known physical phenomena, as discussed in the original article hence, as careful readers will recognise, the formalism used is canonical scattering theory, and cannot be anything other. In fact, there is no new fundamental physics here to dispute whatsoever, and nor was this the raison d'etre of the original article. Additionally, rebuttal (2) provides the opportunity to discuss, at length, some of these textbook aspects of photoionization theory, and we hope this discussion might be of service to new researchers entering this challenging field.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑